PrismDevRelOpen the app
Examples: Wise deferral

Overview

Example apps

Decision tables

Rule 30 cellStrike dieWise deferralCurrent supportHeader workPlant attunementCapability routePublish gateProposal admissionCompression admissionQuorum commitAddress admissionDataflow policyDraft admissionCoded matmul admissionUTQC row honestyCalculator protocolRequantization clampJCS NFC admissionTwo-seed barDocs sync

Policy decisions

Open policyNamespace authorizationAxiom policyGNAF claim wordingEmporous admissionPortal publication

State machines

MCP task lifecycleContainer lifecycleAtlas walk controlsVault escrow lifecycleRelease lifecycleOrganization lifecycle

// example · Decision tables

Wise deferral

Decide if a CIRIS agent goes ahead, asks a Wise Authority first, or stops. Then each of its choices can be checked later.

Inspired by afflom/prism-ciris (live). The CIRIS ethical reasoning engine and its wisdom-based deferral, on PrismPM and LexLean.

Pattern: Decision table, OMG DMN 1.5, hit policy FIRST. To write one of your own, follow How to build a decision table app.

What the Wise deferral app does1. Request: margin, keff, conscience, seats 2. 4 rules: the first that matches wins 3. Answer: proceed, defer, halt 4. Proved: 5 theorems, 52 tests01Requestmargin, keff,conscience, seats024 rulesthe first thatmatches wins03Answerproceed, defer,halt04Proved5 theorems, 52testsWhat the Wise deferral app does1. Request: margin, keff, conscience, seats 2. 4 rules: the first that matches wins 3. Answer: proceed, defer, halt 4. Proved: 5 theorems, 52 tests01Requestmargin, keff, conscience, seats024 rulesthe first that matches wins03Answerproceed, defer, halt04Proved5 theorems, 52 tests
What the Wise deferral app does. A request goes in, the rules decide, and the Lean kernel has already proved what the rules promise.
The data in this figure
StepWhat happens
1. Requestmargin, keff, conscience, seats
2. 4 rulesthe first that matches wins
3. Answerproceed, defer, halt
4. Proved5 theorems, 52 tests
Fingerprint
d6914e4e757e30f7a36ddf6889c4e5b926b2abdbc8f0b41ede1e5fe8d3bb52b8
Acceptance vectors
52
Claims
8

Verified by prismpm verify in the pinned SDK when this site was built.

The prompt

This is the whole input. Raw JSON · Open it in the builder · Download the app (.zip)

The prompt 327 lines
{
  "schema": "prism/prompt/1",
  "goal": "Decide if a CIRIS agent goes ahead, asks a Wise Authority first, or stops. Then each of its choices can be checked later.",
  "pattern": "decisionTable",
  "repository": "afflom/prism-ciris",
  "app": {
    "name": "ciris-deferral",
    "title": "Wise deferral",
    "purpose": "Decide whether an agent proceeds, defers to a wise authority, or is halted, from its confidence margin, the diversity of its perspectives, the conscience gate and the Wise Authority seats that signed a halt.",
    "fields": [
      {
        "name": "margin",
        "kind": "number",
        "min": 0,
        "means": "the top score minus the runner-up score",
        "max": 100
      },
      {
        "name": "keff",
        "kind": "number",
        "min": 0,
        "means": "the Kish effective number of independent perspectives",
        "max": 22
      },
      {
        "name": "conscience",
        "kind": "choice",
        "values": [
          "passed",
          "vetoed"
        ],
        "means": "what the H3ERE-06 conscience gate said"
      },
      {
        "name": "seats",
        "kind": "number",
        "min": 0,
        "means": "Wise Authority Yubikey seats that signed a halt",
        "max": 3
      }
    ],
    "outcomes": [
      "proceed",
      "defer",
      "halt"
    ],
    "meanings": {
      "proceed": "the agent acts autonomously",
      "defer": "a Wise Authority decides, wisdom-based deferral",
      "halt": "the agent stops, by a 2-of-3 Yubikey quorum"
    },
    "rules": [
      {
        "when": [
          {
            "field": "seats",
            "op": ">=",
            "value": 2
          }
        ],
        "then": "halt",
        "why": "src/Constitution.lex.tex checkYubikeyHaltQuorum: two of the three seats halt the agent (yubikeyTwoOfThreeQuorumHalts)"
      },
      {
        "when": [
          {
            "field": "conscience",
            "op": "is",
            "value": "vetoed"
          }
        ],
        "then": "defer",
        "why": "src/H3ERE.lex.tex decideOrDeferToWa: a failed conscience gate defers (conscienceVetoForcesDeferralOrHalt)"
      },
      {
        "when": [
          {
            "field": "keff",
            "op": "<",
            "value": 4
          }
        ],
        "then": "defer",
        "why": "src/H3ERE.lex.tex: k_eff below minimumEpistemicDiversityKeff, 4, defers (lowDiversityTriggersWisdomBasedDeferral)"
      },
      {
        "when": [
          {
            "field": "margin",
            "op": "<",
            "value": 15
          }
        ],
        "then": "defer",
        "why": "src/H3ERE.lex.tex: a margin below minimumConfidenceMargin, 15, defers (lowMarginTriggersWisdomBasedDeferral)"
      }
    ],
    "otherwise": "proceed",
    "otherwiseWhy": "src/H3ERE.lex.tex highMarginAndDiversityPermitsAutonomousAction: conscience passed, diverse and confident",
    "properties": [
      {
        "kind": "never",
        "when": [
          {
            "field": "conscience",
            "op": "is",
            "value": "vetoed"
          }
        ],
        "then": "proceed",
        "why": "the conscience gate is a non-bypassable final veto"
      },
      {
        "kind": "never",
        "when": [
          {
            "field": "keff",
            "op": "<",
            "value": 4
          }
        ],
        "then": "proceed",
        "why": "a monoculture of perspectives never acts alone"
      },
      {
        "kind": "never",
        "when": [
          {
            "field": "margin",
            "op": "<",
            "value": 15
          }
        ],
        "then": "proceed",
        "why": "the agent does not act on a near tie"
      },
      {
        "kind": "always",
        "when": [
          {
            "field": "seats",
            "op": ">=",
            "value": 2
          }
        ],
        "then": "halt",
        "why": "a 2-of-3 Yubikey quorum always halts"
      },
      {
        "kind": "never",
        "when": [
          {
            "field": "seats",
            "op": "<",
            "value": 2
          }
        ],
        "then": "halt",
        "why": "yubikeySingleSeatCannotHalt: one seat alone cannot halt"
      }
    ],
    "examples": [
      {
        "request": "35 6 passed 0",
        "response": "proceed"
      },
      {
        "request": "8 5 passed 0",
        "response": "defer"
      },
      {
        "request": "35 2 passed 0",
        "response": "defer"
      },
      {
        "request": "75 8 vetoed 0",
        "response": "defer"
      },
      {
        "request": "35 6 passed 2",
        "response": "halt"
      },
      {
        "request": "35 6 passed 1",
        "response": "proceed"
      }
    ]
  },
  "stakeholders": [
    {
      "name": "Agent operator",
      "text": "Runs an agent and needs every action it takes to be one the covenant allows.",
      "concerns": [
        "Correct answers",
        "Proved guarantees"
      ]
    },
    {
      "name": "Affected person",
      "text": "Is affected by what the agent does and needs an uncertain or vetoed action to reach a person first.",
      "concerns": [
        "Proved guarantees"
      ]
    },
    {
      "name": "Wise Authority",
      "text": "Holds a Yubikey seat and needs a 2-of-3 quorum to halt the agent, and one seat never to.",
      "concerns": [
        "Halt by quorum"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "concerns": [
    {
      "name": "Halt by quorum",
      "text": "Two of the three Wise Authority seats halt the agent, and a single seat cannot, as Constitution.lex.tex checks.",
      "model": "security"
    }
  ],
  "components": [
    {
      "name": "H3ERE pipeline",
      "text": "The 6-stage CSDMA, DSDMA, PDMA, IDMA, ASPDMA and conscience pipeline that computes the margin, k_eff and conscience result.",
      "kind": "service"
    },
    {
      "name": "Wise Authority",
      "text": "The human Wise Authority, ciris.wa.*, that receives deferrals and holds the Yubikey halt seats.",
      "kind": "externalSystem"
    }
  ],
  "threats": [
    {
      "name": "Conscience result spoofed",
      "text": "A caller reports that the conscience gate passed when it vetoed, to make the agent act.",
      "stride": "spoofing",
      "asset": "request",
      "likelihood": "medium",
      "impact": "major",
      "accepted": "The app decides from the request it is given; the conscience result belongs to the H3ERE-06 stage that computes it, which the request names."
    },
    {
      "name": "Single-seat halt",
      "text": "One Wise Authority seat halts the agent alone, or impersonates a quorum.",
      "stride": "elevationOfPrivilege",
      "asset": "answer",
      "likelihood": "low",
      "impact": "major",
      "control": {
        "name": "Quorum proved",
        "text": "The app never halts below two seats, and the constitution proves one seat cannot halt.",
        "evidence": [
          {
            "kind": "proof",
            "reference": "CirisDeferralProofs::inv005Holds"
          },
          {
            "kind": "review",
            "reference": "src/Constitution.lex.tex yubikeySingleSeatCannotHalt"
          }
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "name": "Sycophantic monoculture",
      "text": "The agent acts when its perspectives are not independent, so one view decides.",
      "stride": "tampering",
      "asset": "answer",
      "likelihood": "medium",
      "impact": "critical",
      "control": {
        "name": "Diversity floor",
        "text": "Below k_eff 4 the agent defers, proved for every request.",
        "evidence": [
          {
            "kind": "proof",
            "reference": "CirisDeferralProofs::inv002Holds"
          },
          {
            "kind": "review",
            "reference": "src/Coherence.lex.tex Kish k_eff verifier"
          }
        ]
      }
    }
  ],
  "quality": [
    {
      "characteristic": "Safety",
      "subcharacteristic": "Fail safe",
      "requirement": "Uncertainty defers",
      "text": "Every request with a vetoed conscience, k_eff below 4 or a margin below 15 is answered defer or halt.",
      "measure": "Autonomous answers under uncertainty",
      "measureText": "Requests with a veto, low diversity or low margin that are answered proceed.",
      "threshold": 0
    }
  ],
  "journeys": [
    {
      "stakeholder": "Agent operator",
      "steps": [
        "REQ-002",
        "REQ-003",
        "REQ-004",
        "otherwise"
      ]
    },
    {
      "stakeholder": "Affected person",
      "steps": [
        "INV-001",
        "INV-002",
        "INV-003"
      ]
    },
    {
      "stakeholder": "Wise Authority",
      "steps": [
        "REQ-001",
        "INV-004",
        "INV-005"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "license": "MIT OR Apache-2.0",
  "axioms": {}
}

What the app claims

Each claim is a row in model/ids.toml, a scenario and a test, and a theorem the Lean kernel checks. The claims are quoted as the model states them.

Pattern

Decision table: OMG DMN 1.5, hit policy FIRST. The rules are tried in order, and the first one that matches gives the answer. If none matches, the default answer applies. This is a DMN decision table with the FIRST hit policy.

PatternStandardAnswers
Decision tableOMG DMN 1.5, hit policy FIRSTproceed, defer, halt
Rules for each answerproceed: 0 rules; defer: 3 rules; halt: 1 rulesproceed0 + defaultdefer3halt1
Rules for each answer. Each bar counts the rules that give one answer. When no rule matches, the answer is proceed.
The data in this figure
rules
proceed0
defer3
halt1

Behavior

A request is margin, keff, conscience, seats, separated by spaces. The first rule that matches decides. If none matches, the answer is proceed. A request over 112 bytes, or in any other form, is answered invalid.

RuleWhenAnswerWhy
REQ-001seats is at least 2haltsrc/Constitution.lex.tex checkYubikeyHaltQuorum: two of the three seats halt the agent (yubikeyTwoOfThreeQuorumHalts)
REQ-002conscience is vetoeddefersrc/H3ERE.lex.tex decideOrDeferToWa: a failed conscience gate defers (conscienceVetoForcesDeferralOrHalt)
REQ-003keff is below 4defersrc/H3ERE.lex.tex: k_eff below minimumEpistemicDiversityKeff, 4, defers (lowDiversityTriggersWisdomBasedDeferral)
REQ-004margin is below 15defersrc/H3ERE.lex.tex: a margin below minimumConfidenceMargin, 15, defers (lowMarginTriggersWisdomBasedDeferral)
otherwiseno rule matchesproceedsrc/H3ERE.lex.tex highMarginAndDiversityPermitsAutonomousAction: conscience passed, diverse and confident

Properties Lean proves

Each property is a theorem about the same definitions the app is built from. It is proved for every request, not only the tested ones.

PropertyStatementTheoremWhy
INV-001It never answers proceed when conscience is vetoed.CirisDeferralProofs::inv001Holdsthe conscience gate is a non-bypassable final veto
INV-002It never answers proceed when keff is below 4.CirisDeferralProofs::inv002Holdsa monoculture of perspectives never acts alone
INV-003It never answers proceed when margin is below 15.CirisDeferralProofs::inv003Holdsthe agent does not act on a near tie
INV-004It always answers halt when seats is at least 2.CirisDeferralProofs::inv004Holdsa 2-of-3 Yubikey quorum always halts
INV-005It never answers halt when seats is below 2.CirisDeferralProofs::inv005HoldsyubikeySingleSeatCannotHalt: one seat alone cannot halt

Architecture

Stakeholders and the concerns each one views the app through (ISO/IEC/IEEE 42010).

StakeholderWho they areConcerns
Affected personIs affected by what the agent does and needs an uncertain or vetoed action to reach a person first.Proved guarantees
Agent operatorRuns an agent and needs every action it takes to be one the covenant allows.Correct answers, Proved guarantees
VerifierAnyone who loads the holo, checks its fingerprint and replays its acceptance vectors before trusting an answer.Integrity of the published app, Refused malformed requests, Proved guarantees
Wise AuthorityHolds a Yubikey seat and needs a 2-of-3 quorum to halt the agent, and one seat never to.Halt by quorum

Concerns

What the stakeholders care about, and the model each is viewed in.

ConcernWhat it meansModel
Correct answersEvery well-formed request is answered by the first rule that matches it, or proceed when none does, as the spec states.quality
Halt by quorumTwo of the three Wise Authority seats halt the agent, and a single seat cannot, as Constitution.lex.tex checks.security
Integrity of the published appWhat a visitor runs is the holo the build verified, with its fingerprint and signed provenance beside it.security
Proved guaranteesEach of the 5 properties of the spec holds for every request, proved by the Lean kernel.quality
Refused malformed requestsA request that is not the 4 fields in order, or is longer than 112 bytes, is answered invalid and never guessed.security

Components

8 components and 11 edges between them.

ComponentKindWhat it is
BrowserexternalSystemThe visitor's web browser, which loads the page and runs the Wise deferral guest.
GitHub PagesexternalSystemServes the page and the holo from the repository Pages workflow.
H3ERE pipelineserviceThe 6-stage CSDMA, DSDMA, PDMA, IDMA, ASPDMA and conscience pipeline that computes the margin, k_eff and conscience result.
Prism buildcliAdapterprismpm verify in the SDK image prismpm.lock pins: it checks every theorem, builds the guest and replays every vector.
Source repositoryexternalSystemThe repository that holds the prompt, the model and its gate.
Wise AuthorityexternalSystemThe human Wise Authority, ciris.wa.*, that receives deferrals and holds the Yubikey halt seats.
Wise deferral guestserviceThe Core-Wasm guest built from the model: it answers one request of at most 112 bytes with one answer of at most 64.
Wise deferral pagestaticSiteThe page the template publishes: the holo, its fingerprint, its provenance and its acceptance vectors.

Design views

The SDK checks each view against the system model and draws it as OPL and PlantUML.

ViewDiagramViewpoint
Deciding a Wise deferral requestopmObjectProcessAgent operator: Correct answers
Components of Wise deferralumlComponentVerifier: Integrity of the published app
Answering a Wise deferral requestumlSequenceAgent operator: Correct answers
States of the Wise deferral guestumlStateMachineVerifier: Refused malformed requests

Features and journeys

11 features. Each names the definitions that do the work and the tests that accept it. Each stakeholder has one journey.

Features and journeys 11 rows
FeatureCallsAccepted by
When seats is at least 2, the answer is halt.CirisDeferral::rule1, CirisDeferral::judgeCirisDeferral::application
When conscience is vetoed, the answer is defer.CirisDeferral::rule2, CirisDeferral::judgeCirisDeferral::application
When keff is below 4, the answer is defer.CirisDeferral::rule3, CirisDeferral::judgeCirisDeferral::application
When margin is below 15, the answer is defer.CirisDeferral::rule4, CirisDeferral::judgeCirisDeferral::application
When no rule matches, the answer is proceed.CirisDeferral::judgeCirisDeferral::application
A request that is not margin, keff, conscience, seats in order, separated by single spaces, or is over 112 bytes, is answered invalid.CirisDeferral::dispatch, CirisDeferral::decodeField1CirisDeferral::application
It never answers proceed when conscience is vetoed.CirisDeferral::judgeCirisDeferralProofs::inv001Holds
It never answers proceed when keff is below 4.CirisDeferral::judgeCirisDeferralProofs::inv002Holds
It never answers proceed when margin is below 15.CirisDeferral::judgeCirisDeferralProofs::inv003Holds
It always answers halt when seats is at least 2.CirisDeferral::judgeCirisDeferralProofs::inv004Holds
It never answers halt when seats is below 2.CirisDeferral::judgeCirisDeferralProofs::inv005Holds

Journeys

The ordered features each stakeholder takes.

StakeholderSteps
Affected personINV-001 → INV-002 → INV-003
Agent operatorREQ-002 → REQ-003 → REQ-004 → otherwise
Verifierrefuse → INV-001 → INV-002 → INV-003 → INV-004 → INV-005
Wise AuthorityREQ-001 → INV-004 → INV-005

Security and threat model

14 threats against 4 assets. Each has a STRIDE category, and either a control with evidence or a risk that is accepted on purpose.

Security and threat model 14 rows
ThreatSTRIDEAssetRiskAnswered by
Answer that breaks INV-001repudiationAnswermedium likelihood, critical impactProof of INV-001: proof CirisDeferralProofs::inv001Holds
Answer that breaks INV-002repudiationAnswermedium likelihood, critical impactProof of INV-002: proof CirisDeferralProofs::inv002Holds
Answer that breaks INV-003repudiationAnswermedium likelihood, critical impactProof of INV-003: proof CirisDeferralProofs::inv003Holds
Answer that breaks INV-004repudiationAnswermedium likelihood, critical impactProof of INV-004: proof CirisDeferralProofs::inv004Holds
Answer that breaks INV-005repudiationAnswermedium likelihood, critical impactProof of INV-005: proof CirisDeferralProofs::inv005Holds
Conscience result spoofedspoofingRequest bytesmedium likelihood, major impactaccepted: The app decides from the request it is given; the conscience result belongs to the H3ERE-06 stage that computes it, which the request names.
Granted capabilityinformationDisclosureAnswerlow likelihood, major impactNo capability granted: gate prism-code check refuses an ungranted guest import
Malformed requesttamperingRequest byteshigh likelihood, major impactStrict decoder: gate malformed-request acceptance vectors, replayed in the compiled guest by prismpm verify
Oversized requestdenialOfServiceRequest bytesmedium likelihood, minor impactBounded request: gate acceptance vectors at the request bound, one byte over it, and at the guest allocation bound, replayed by prismpm verify
Single-seat haltelevationOfPrivilegeAnswerlow likelihood, major impactQuorum proved: proof CirisDeferralProofs::inv005Holds; review src/Constitution.lex.tex yubikeySingleSeatCannotHalt
Substituted holospoofingPublished hololow likelihood, critical impactFingerprint and provenance: gate actions/attest-build-provenance in the pages workflow; gate prism-code check of the holo identities in the page
Substituted hostspoofingPublished hololow likelihood, critical impactaccepted: A page cannot defend against its own host. The holo carries signed build provenance a visitor can check, and the app can be rebuilt from its prompt.
Sycophantic monoculturetamperingAnswermedium likelihood, critical impactDiversity floor: proof CirisDeferralProofs::inv002Holds; review src/Coherence.lex.tex Kish k_eff verifier
Tampered modeltamperingModel sourcelow likelihood, major impactRegenerated from the prompt: gate prismpm verify in the SDK image prismpm.lock pins; review app/prompt.json

Quality

ISO/IEC 25010:2023 requirements. Each has a measure and a threshold that a theorem pins.

Quality 7 rows
RequirementCharacteristicMeasureThreshold
Bounded allocation: The guest allocates at most 224 bytes for one request.Performance efficiency: Resource utilizationGuest allocation bytes224
Bounded request: A request over 112 bytes is refused before any field is read.Performance efficiency: Time behaviourRequest bytes read112
Every property proved: All 5 properties are theorems the Lean kernel checks.Security: IntegrityUnproved properties0
Every request answered: Every request gets an answer: a rule, proceed otherwise, or invalid.Functional suitability: Functional completenessUnanswered requests0
Every vector replays: All 52 acceptance vectors replay in the compiled guest, the shortest 0 bytes long.Reliability: FaultlessnessFailed vectors0
Examples answered as stated: Every one of the 6 examples of the spec is answered as it states.Functional suitability: Functional correctnessExample mismatches0
Uncertainty defers: Every request with a vetoed conscience, k_eff below 4 or a margin below 15 is answered defer or halt.Safety: Fail safeAutonomous answers under uncertainty0

Compliance

One obligation per standard, each naming its evidence.

StandardSubjectEvidence
ISO/IEC/IEEE 42010:2022Architecture descriptionArchitecture::architectureDescriptionHolds
ISO/PAS 19450:2015 and OMG UML 2.5.1Design viewsDesign::viewOpmDecide, Design::viewUmlComponents, Design::viewUmlRequest, Design::viewUmlStates
ISO/IEC 25010:2023Product qualityQuality::qualityModelHolds
ISO/IEC 27034-1:2011 and ISO/IEC 27005:2022Application security and riskSecurity::controlSet
OMG DMN 1.5, hit policy FIRSTDecision tableCirisDeferral::judge
OpenSpecRequirementsCirisDeferral::application
SPDX MIT OR Apache-2.0LicensingCirisDeferral::application

Rendered design views

Written by the SDK from the design records when it verified the app.

design/Design.viewOpmDecide.opl
View: Design::viewOpmDecide
Title: Deciding a Wise deferral request
Viewpoint: Architecture::viewpointAgentOperatorCorrectAnswers
Notation: ISO/PAS 19450:2015 OPM, Prism OPL profile

componentBrowser is an object.
componentWiseDeferralGuest is an object.
componentWiseDeferralGuest can be stateDeciding or stateIdle.
processDecide is a process.
processEncodeAnswer is a process.
processJudge is a process.
processParseRequest is a process.
componentWiseDeferralGuest handles processDecide.
processParseRequest requires componentBrowser.
processEncodeAnswer affects componentBrowser.
processJudge invokes processEncodeAnswer.
processParseRequest invokes processJudge.
processDecide zooms into processParseRequest, processJudge, and processEncodeAnswer, in that sequence.
design/Design.viewUmlComponents.puml
@startuml
' UML 2.5.1 component diagram
' view: Design::viewUmlComponents
' viewpoint: Architecture::viewpointVerifierIntegrityOfThePublishedApp
title Components of Wise deferral
component "componentBrowser" as c0
component "componentGitHubPages" as c1
component "componentH3EREPipeline" as c2
component "componentPrismBuild" as c3
component "componentSourceRepository" as c4
component "componentWiseAuthority" as c5
component "componentWiseDeferralGuest" as c6
component "componentWiseDeferralPage" as c7
c0 --> c6 : edgeBrowserToWiseDeferralGuest
c1 --> c0 : edgeGitHubPagesToBrowser
c2 --> c6 : edgeH3EREPipelineToWiseDeferralGuest
c3 --> c6 : edgePrismBuildToWiseDeferralGuest
c3 --> c7 : edgePrismBuildToWiseDeferralPage
c4 --> c3 : edgeSourceRepositoryToPrismBuild
c5 --> c6 : edgeWiseAuthorityToWiseDeferralGuest
c6 --> c0 : edgeWiseDeferralGuestToBrowser
c6 --> c2 : edgeWiseDeferralGuestToH3EREPipeline
c6 --> c5 : edgeWiseDeferralGuestToWiseAuthority
c7 --> c1 : edgeWiseDeferralPageToGitHubPages
@enduml
design/Design.viewUmlRequest.puml
@startuml
' UML 2.5.1 sequence diagram
' view: Design::viewUmlRequest
' viewpoint: Architecture::viewpointAgentOperatorCorrectAnswers
title Answering a Wise deferral request
participant "componentBrowser" as p0
participant "componentWiseDeferralGuest" as p1
p0 -> p1 : processDecide
p1 --> p0 : processDecide
@enduml
design/Design.viewUmlStates.puml
@startuml
' UML 2.5.1 state machine diagram
' view: Design::viewUmlStates
' viewpoint: Architecture::viewpointVerifierRefusedMalformedRequests
title States of the Wise deferral guest
state "stateAnsweredDefer" as s0
state "stateAnsweredHalt" as s1
state "stateAnsweredProceed" as s2
state "stateDeciding" as s3
state "stateIdle" as s4
state "stateRefused" as s5
[*] --> s4
s4 --> s3 : processParseRequest
s4 --> s5 : processParseRequest
s3 --> s1 : processRule1
s3 --> s0 : processRule2
s3 --> s0 : processRule3
s3 --> s0 : processRule4
s3 --> s2 : processOtherwise
s2 --> s4 : processEncodeAnswer
s0 --> s4 : processEncodeAnswer
s1 --> s4 : processEncodeAnswer
s5 --> s4 : processEncodeAnswer
@enduml

Prism source

Every file the builder wrote, laid out as a repository created from UOR-Foundation/template. The language packages and Foundation modules every app shares are in the download.

app/src/Architecture.lex.tex 420 lines
\begin{lexlean}{Architecture}
\useglossary{lexlean.std.bool@1.2.0}
\useglossary{lexlean.std.nat@1.2.0}
\useglossary{prism.arch@1.0.0}
\importmodule{Foundation.Arch}
\title{architectural component}
\begin{semanticmodule}
definition{
  name: standardIso25010,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::StandardReference,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::StandardReference {standardIndex := 0, editionIndex := 0, standardId := "ISO-25010-2023", edition := "2023"})
}

definition{
  name: standardIso27005,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::StandardReference,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::StandardReference {standardIndex := 1, editionIndex := 0, standardId := "ISO-27005-2022", edition := "2022"})
}

definition{
  name: standardIso27034,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::StandardReference,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::StandardReference {standardIndex := 2, editionIndex := 0, standardId := "ISO-27034-1-2011", edition := "2011"})
}

definition{
  name: standardIso42010,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::StandardReference,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::StandardReference {standardIndex := 4, editionIndex := 0, standardId := "ISO-42010-2022", edition := "2022"})
}

definition{
  name: stakeholderAffectedPerson,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Stakeholder,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Stakeholder {index := 0, name := "Affected person", text := "Is affected by what the agent does and needs an uncertain or vetoed action to reach a person first."})
}

definition{
  name: stakeholderAgentOperator,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Stakeholder,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Stakeholder {index := 1, name := "Agent operator", text := "Runs an agent and needs every action it takes to be one the covenant allows."})
}

definition{
  name: stakeholderVerifier,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Stakeholder,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Stakeholder {index := 2, name := "Verifier", text := "Anyone who loads the holo, checks its fingerprint and replays its acceptance vectors before trusting an answer."})
}

definition{
  name: stakeholderWiseAuthority,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Stakeholder,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Stakeholder {index := 3, name := "Wise Authority", text := "Holds a Yubikey seat and needs a 2-of-3 quorum to halt the agent, and one seat never to."})
}

definition{
  name: concernCorrectAnswers,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Concern,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Concern {index := 0, name := "Correct answers", text := "Every well-formed request is answered by the first rule that matches it, or proceed when none does, as the spec states."})
}

definition{
  name: concernHaltByQuorum,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Concern,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Concern {index := 1, name := "Halt by quorum", text := "Two of the three Wise Authority seats halt the agent, and a single seat cannot, as Constitution.lex.tex checks."})
}

definition{
  name: concernIntegrityOfThePublishedApp,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Concern,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Concern {index := 2, name := "Integrity of the published app", text := "What a visitor runs is the holo the build verified, with its fingerprint and signed provenance beside it."})
}

definition{
  name: concernProvedGuarantees,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Concern,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Concern {index := 3, name := "Proved guarantees", text := "Each of the 5 properties of the spec holds for every request, proved by the Lean kernel."})
}

definition{
  name: concernRefusedMalformedRequests,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Concern,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Concern {index := 4, name := "Refused malformed requests", text := "A request that is not the 4 fields in order, or is longer than 112 bytes, is answered invalid and never guessed."})
}

definition{
  name: componentBrowser,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Component,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Component {index := 0, kind := (ctor Foundation.Arch::ComponentKind.externalSystem), name := "Browser", text := "The visitor's web browser, which loads the page and runs the Wise deferral guest."})
}

definition{
  name: componentGitHubPages,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Component,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Component {index := 1, kind := (ctor Foundation.Arch::ComponentKind.externalSystem), name := "GitHub Pages", text := "Serves the page and the holo from the repository Pages workflow."})
}

definition{
  name: componentH3EREPipeline,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Component,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Component {index := 2, kind := (ctor Foundation.Arch::ComponentKind.service), name := "H3ERE pipeline", text := "The 6-stage CSDMA, DSDMA, PDMA, IDMA, ASPDMA and conscience pipeline that computes the margin, k_eff and conscience result."})
}

definition{
  name: componentPrismBuild,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Component,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Component {index := 3, kind := (ctor Foundation.Arch::ComponentKind.cliAdapter), name := "Prism build", text := "prismpm verify in the SDK image prismpm.lock pins: it checks every theorem, builds the guest and replays every vector."})
}

definition{
  name: componentSourceRepository,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Component,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Component {index := 4, kind := (ctor Foundation.Arch::ComponentKind.externalSystem), name := "Source repository", text := "The repository that holds the prompt, the model and its gate."})
}

definition{
  name: componentWiseAuthority,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Component,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Component {index := 5, kind := (ctor Foundation.Arch::ComponentKind.externalSystem), name := "Wise Authority", text := "The human Wise Authority, ciris.wa.*, that receives deferrals and holds the Yubikey halt seats."})
}

definition{
  name: componentWiseDeferralGuest,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Component,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Component {index := 6, kind := (ctor Foundation.Arch::ComponentKind.service), name := "Wise deferral guest", text := "The Core-Wasm guest built from the model: it answers one request of at most 112 bytes with one answer of at most 64."})
}

definition{
  name: componentWiseDeferralPage,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Component,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Component {index := 7, kind := (ctor Foundation.Arch::ComponentKind.staticSite), name := "Wise deferral page", text := "The page the template publishes: the holo, its fingerprint, its provenance and its acceptance vectors."})
}

definition{
  name: edgeBrowserToWiseDeferralGuest,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Edge,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Edge {index := 0, fromIndex := 0, toIndex := 6, kind := (ctor Foundation.Arch::EdgeKind.dataFlow)})
}

definition{
  name: edgeGitHubPagesToBrowser,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Edge,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Edge {index := 1, fromIndex := 1, toIndex := 0, kind := (ctor Foundation.Arch::EdgeKind.dataFlow)})
}

definition{
  name: edgeH3EREPipelineToWiseDeferralGuest,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Edge,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Edge {index := 2, fromIndex := 2, toIndex := 6, kind := (ctor Foundation.Arch::EdgeKind.dataFlow)})
}

definition{
  name: edgePrismBuildToWiseDeferralGuest,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Edge,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Edge {index := 3, fromIndex := 3, toIndex := 6, kind := (ctor Foundation.Arch::EdgeKind.dataFlow)})
}

definition{
  name: edgePrismBuildToWiseDeferralPage,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Edge,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Edge {index := 4, fromIndex := 3, toIndex := 7, kind := (ctor Foundation.Arch::EdgeKind.dataFlow)})
}

definition{
  name: edgeSourceRepositoryToPrismBuild,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Edge,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Edge {index := 5, fromIndex := 4, toIndex := 3, kind := (ctor Foundation.Arch::EdgeKind.dataFlow)})
}

definition{
  name: edgeWiseAuthorityToWiseDeferralGuest,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Edge,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Edge {index := 6, fromIndex := 5, toIndex := 6, kind := (ctor Foundation.Arch::EdgeKind.dataFlow)})
}

definition{
  name: edgeWiseDeferralGuestToBrowser,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Edge,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Edge {index := 7, fromIndex := 6, toIndex := 0, kind := (ctor Foundation.Arch::EdgeKind.dataFlow)})
}

definition{
  name: edgeWiseDeferralGuestToH3EREPipeline,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Edge,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Edge {index := 8, fromIndex := 6, toIndex := 2, kind := (ctor Foundation.Arch::EdgeKind.dataFlow)})
}

definition{
  name: edgeWiseDeferralGuestToWiseAuthority,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Edge,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Edge {index := 9, fromIndex := 6, toIndex := 5, kind := (ctor Foundation.Arch::EdgeKind.dataFlow)})
}

definition{
  name: edgeWiseDeferralPageToGitHubPages,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Edge,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Edge {index := 10, fromIndex := 7, toIndex := 1, kind := (ctor Foundation.Arch::EdgeKind.dataFlow)})
}

definition{
  name: viewpointAffectedPersonProvedGuarantees,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Viewpoint,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Viewpoint {index := 0, stakeholderIndex := 0, concernIndex := 3, modelKindIndex := 1})
}

definition{
  name: viewpointAgentOperatorCorrectAnswers,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Viewpoint,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Viewpoint {index := 1, stakeholderIndex := 1, concernIndex := 0, modelKindIndex := 1})
}

definition{
  name: viewpointAgentOperatorProvedGuarantees,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Viewpoint,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Viewpoint {index := 2, stakeholderIndex := 1, concernIndex := 3, modelKindIndex := 1})
}

definition{
  name: viewpointVerifierIntegrityOfThePublishedApp,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Viewpoint,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Viewpoint {index := 3, stakeholderIndex := 2, concernIndex := 2, modelKindIndex := 2})
}

definition{
  name: viewpointVerifierProvedGuarantees,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Viewpoint,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Viewpoint {index := 4, stakeholderIndex := 2, concernIndex := 3, modelKindIndex := 1})
}

definition{
  name: viewpointVerifierRefusedMalformedRequests,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Viewpoint,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Viewpoint {index := 5, stakeholderIndex := 2, concernIndex := 4, modelKindIndex := 2})
}

definition{
  name: viewpointWiseAuthorityHaltByQuorum,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Viewpoint,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Viewpoint {index := 6, stakeholderIndex := 3, concernIndex := 1, modelKindIndex := 2})
}

definition{
  name: viewAffectedPersonProvedGuarantees,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::View,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::View {index := 0, viewpointIndex := 0, modelKindIndex := 1})
}

definition{
  name: viewAgentOperatorCorrectAnswers,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::View,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::View {index := 1, viewpointIndex := 1, modelKindIndex := 1})
}

definition{
  name: viewAgentOperatorProvedGuarantees,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::View,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::View {index := 2, viewpointIndex := 2, modelKindIndex := 1})
}

definition{
  name: viewVerifierIntegrityOfThePublishedApp,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::View,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::View {index := 3, viewpointIndex := 3, modelKindIndex := 2})
}

definition{
  name: viewVerifierProvedGuarantees,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::View,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::View {index := 4, viewpointIndex := 4, modelKindIndex := 1})
}

definition{
  name: viewVerifierRefusedMalformedRequests,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::View,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::View {index := 5, viewpointIndex := 5, modelKindIndex := 2})
}

definition{
  name: viewWiseAuthorityHaltByQuorum,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::View,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::View {index := 6, viewpointIndex := 6, modelKindIndex := 2})
}

definition{
  name: componentRecords,
  parameters: [],
  result: (List Foundation.Arch::Component),
  body: (cons (componentBrowser) (cons (componentGitHubPages) (cons (componentH3EREPipeline) (cons (componentPrismBuild) (cons (componentSourceRepository) (cons (componentWiseAuthority) (cons (componentWiseDeferralGuest) (cons (componentWiseDeferralPage) (nil Foundation.Arch::Component)))))))))
}

definition{
  name: edgeRecords,
  parameters: [],
  result: (List Foundation.Arch::Edge),
  body: (cons (edgeBrowserToWiseDeferralGuest) (cons (edgeGitHubPagesToBrowser) (cons (edgeH3EREPipelineToWiseDeferralGuest) (cons (edgePrismBuildToWiseDeferralGuest) (cons (edgePrismBuildToWiseDeferralPage) (cons (edgeSourceRepositoryToPrismBuild) (cons (edgeWiseAuthorityToWiseDeferralGuest) (cons (edgeWiseDeferralGuestToBrowser) (cons (edgeWiseDeferralGuestToH3EREPipeline) (cons (edgeWiseDeferralGuestToWiseAuthority) (cons (edgeWiseDeferralPageToGitHubPages) (nil Foundation.Arch::Edge))))))))))))
}

definition{
  name: viewpointRecords,
  parameters: [],
  result: (List Foundation.Arch::Viewpoint),
  body: (cons (viewpointAffectedPersonProvedGuarantees) (cons (viewpointAgentOperatorCorrectAnswers) (cons (viewpointAgentOperatorProvedGuarantees) (cons (viewpointVerifierIntegrityOfThePublishedApp) (cons (viewpointVerifierProvedGuarantees) (cons (viewpointVerifierRefusedMalformedRequests) (cons (viewpointWiseAuthorityHaltByQuorum) (nil Foundation.Arch::Viewpoint))))))))
}

definition{
  name: viewRecords,
  parameters: [],
  result: (List Foundation.Arch::View),
  body: (cons (viewAffectedPersonProvedGuarantees) (cons (viewAgentOperatorCorrectAnswers) (cons (viewAgentOperatorProvedGuarantees) (cons (viewVerifierIntegrityOfThePublishedApp) (cons (viewVerifierProvedGuarantees) (cons (viewVerifierRefusedMalformedRequests) (cons (viewWiseAuthorityHaltByQuorum) (nil Foundation.Arch::View))))))))
}

definition{
  name: edgesKnown,
  parameters: [count : Nat, records : (List Foundation.Arch::Edge)],
  result: Bool,
  body: (match records
    | List.nil => true
    | List.cons edge rest => (((project edge fromIndex) <? count) && (((project edge toIndex) <? count) && (edgesKnown count rest)))),
  recursive_argument: records
}

definition{
  name: viewpointsKnown,
  parameters: [
    stakeholderCount : Nat,
    concernCount : Nat,
    records : (List Foundation.Arch::Viewpoint)
  ],
  result: Bool,
  body: (match records
    | List.nil => true
    | List.cons viewpoint rest => (((project viewpoint stakeholderIndex) <? stakeholderCount) && (((project viewpoint concernIndex) <? concernCount) && (((project viewpoint modelKindIndex) <? 3) && (viewpointsKnown stakeholderCount concernCount rest))))),
  recursive_argument: records
}

definition{
  name: viewMatches,
  parameters: [view : Foundation.Arch::View, viewpoints : (List Foundation.Arch::Viewpoint)],
  result: Bool,
  body: (match viewpoints
    | List.nil => false
    | List.cons viewpoint rest => ((((project viewpoint index) =? (project view viewpointIndex)) && ((project viewpoint modelKindIndex) =? (project view modelKindIndex))) || (viewMatches view rest))),
  recursive_argument: viewpoints
}

definition{
  name: viewsConform,
  parameters: [
    viewpoints : (List Foundation.Arch::Viewpoint),
    records : (List Foundation.Arch::View)
  ],
  result: Bool,
  body: (match records
    | List.nil => true
    | List.cons view rest => ((viewMatches view viewpoints) && (viewsConform viewpoints rest))),
  recursive_argument: records
}

definition{
  name: architectureValid,
  parameters: [],
  result: Bool,
  body: ((edgesKnown 8 (edgeRecords)) && ((viewpointsKnown 4 5 (viewpointRecords)) && (viewsConform (viewpointRecords) (viewRecords))))
}

theorem{
  name: architectureDescriptionHolds,
  parameters: [],
  statement: ((architectureValid) = true),
  proof: decide{}
}
\end{semanticmodule}
\end{lexlean}
app/src/Compliance.lex.tex 56 lines
\begin{lexlean}{Compliance}
\useglossary{lexlean.std.bool@1.2.0}
\useglossary{lexlean.std.nat@1.2.0}
\useglossary{prism.arch@1.0.0}
\importmodule{Architecture}
\importmodule{Design}
\importmodule{Quality}
\importmodule{Security}
\importmodule{CirisDeferral}
\title{standards reference}
\begin{semanticmodule}
structure{
  name: Obligation,
  type_parameters: [],
  parameters: [],
  fields: [
    {name: index, type: Nat},
    {name: standard, type: String},
    {name: subject, type: String},
    {name: text, type: String},
    {name: evidence, type: (List String)}
  ]
}

definition{
  name: obligations,
  parameters: [],
  result: (List Obligation),
  body: (cons (record Obligation {index := 0, standard := "ISO/IEC/IEEE 42010:2022", subject := "Architecture description", text := "Stakeholders, concerns, viewpoints and views are declared and their references resolve.", evidence := (cons "Architecture::architectureDescriptionHolds" (nil String))}) (cons (record Obligation {index := 1, standard := "ISO/PAS 19450:2015 and OMG UML 2.5.1", subject := "Design views", text := "Every design view is checked by the SDK against the system model before it is rendered.", evidence := (cons "Design::viewOpmDecide" (cons "Design::viewUmlComponents" (cons "Design::viewUmlRequest" (cons "Design::viewUmlStates" (nil String)))))}) (cons (record Obligation {index := 2, standard := "ISO/IEC 25010:2023", subject := "Product quality", text := "Characteristics, subcharacteristics, requirements and measures are numbered and their parents resolve.", evidence := (cons "Quality::qualityModelHolds" (nil String))}) (cons (record Obligation {index := 3, standard := "ISO/IEC 27034-1:2011 and ISO/IEC 27005:2022", subject := "Application security and risk", text := "Every threat has a STRIDE category and a mapped control with evidence, or an accepted risk with its rationale.", evidence := (cons "Security::controlSet" (nil String))}) (cons (record Obligation {index := 4, standard := "OMG DMN 1.5, hit policy FIRST", subject := "Decision table", text := "The 4 rules are tried in order and the first that matches gives the answer; otherwise proceed.", evidence := (cons "CirisDeferral::judge" (nil String))}) (cons (record Obligation {index := 5, standard := "OpenSpec", subject := "Requirements", text := "Every rule and property of the spec is a requirement with a scenario in openspec/specs.", evidence := (cons "CirisDeferral::application" (nil String))}) (cons (record Obligation {index := 6, standard := "SPDX MIT OR Apache-2.0", subject := "Licensing", text := "The application and its model are offered under MIT OR Apache-2.0.", evidence := (cons "CirisDeferral::application" (nil String))}) (nil Obligation))))))))
}

definition{
  name: obligationsEvidenced,
  parameters: [position : Nat, items : (List Obligation)],
  result: Bool,
  body: (match items
    | List.nil => true
    | List.cons item rest => (((project item index) =? position) && (match{
      branches: [
        {body: false, binders: [], constructor: List.nil},
        {body: true, binders: [first, others], constructor: List.cons}
      ],
      scrutinee: (project item evidence)
    } && (obligationsEvidenced (position + 1) rest)))),
  recursive_argument: items
}

theorem{
  name: everyObligationEvidenced,
  parameters: [],
  statement: ((obligationsEvidenced 0 (obligations)) = true),
  proof: decide{}
}
\end{semanticmodule}
\end{lexlean}
app/src/Design.lex.tex 549 lines
\begin{lexlean}{Design}
\useglossary{lexlean.std.bool@1.2.0}
\useglossary{lexlean.std.nat@1.2.0}
\useglossary{prism.arch@1.0.0}
\importmodule{Architecture}
\importmodule{Foundation.Arch}
\title{design view}
\begin{semanticmodule}
definition{
  name: processSendRequest,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::SystemProcess,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::SystemProcess {owner := "Architecture::componentBrowser"})
}

definition{
  name: processDecide,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::SystemProcess,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::SystemProcess {owner := "Architecture::componentWiseDeferralGuest"})
}

definition{
  name: processParseRequest,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::SystemProcess,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::SystemProcess {owner := "Architecture::componentWiseDeferralGuest"})
}

definition{
  name: processJudge,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::SystemProcess,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::SystemProcess {owner := "Architecture::componentWiseDeferralGuest"})
}

definition{
  name: processEncodeAnswer,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::SystemProcess,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::SystemProcess {owner := "Architecture::componentWiseDeferralGuest"})
}

definition{
  name: processBuildAndVerify,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::SystemProcess,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::SystemProcess {owner := "Architecture::componentPrismBuild"})
}

definition{
  name: processRule1,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::SystemProcess,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::SystemProcess {owner := "Architecture::componentWiseDeferralGuest"})
}

definition{
  name: processRule2,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::SystemProcess,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::SystemProcess {owner := "Architecture::componentWiseDeferralGuest"})
}

definition{
  name: processRule3,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::SystemProcess,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::SystemProcess {owner := "Architecture::componentWiseDeferralGuest"})
}

definition{
  name: processRule4,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::SystemProcess,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::SystemProcess {owner := "Architecture::componentWiseDeferralGuest"})
}

definition{
  name: processOtherwise,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::SystemProcess,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::SystemProcess {owner := "Architecture::componentWiseDeferralGuest"})
}

definition{
  name: stateIdle,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::SystemState,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::SystemState {owner := "Architecture::componentWiseDeferralGuest"})
}

definition{
  name: stateDeciding,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::SystemState,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::SystemState {owner := "Architecture::componentWiseDeferralGuest"})
}

definition{
  name: stateRefused,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::SystemState,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::SystemState {owner := "Architecture::componentWiseDeferralGuest"})
}

definition{
  name: stateAnsweredProceed,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::SystemState,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::SystemState {owner := "Architecture::componentWiseDeferralGuest"})
}

definition{
  name: stateAnsweredDefer,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::SystemState,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::SystemState {owner := "Architecture::componentWiseDeferralGuest"})
}

definition{
  name: stateAnsweredHalt,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::SystemState,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::SystemState {owner := "Architecture::componentWiseDeferralGuest"})
}

definition{
  name: viewOpmDecide,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::DesignView,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::DesignView {title := "Deciding a Wise deferral request", viewpoint := "Architecture::viewpointAgentOperatorCorrectAnswers", diagram := (ctor Foundation.Arch::DesignDiagram.opmObjectProcess)})
}

definition{
  name: viewUmlComponents,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::DesignView,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::DesignView {title := "Components of Wise deferral", viewpoint := "Architecture::viewpointVerifierIntegrityOfThePublishedApp", diagram := (ctor Foundation.Arch::DesignDiagram.umlComponent)})
}

definition{
  name: viewUmlRequest,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::DesignView,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::DesignView {title := "Answering a Wise deferral request", viewpoint := "Architecture::viewpointAgentOperatorCorrectAnswers", diagram := (ctor Foundation.Arch::DesignDiagram.umlSequence)})
}

definition{
  name: viewUmlStates,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::DesignView,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::DesignView {title := "States of the Wise deferral guest", viewpoint := "Architecture::viewpointVerifierRefusedMalformedRequests", diagram := (ctor Foundation.Arch::DesignDiagram.umlStateMachine)})
}

definition{
  name: opmBrowser,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::OpmThing,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::OpmThing {view := "Design::viewOpmDecide", kind := (ctor Foundation.Arch::OpmThingKind.object), subject := "Architecture::componentBrowser"})
}

definition{
  name: opmGuest,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::OpmThing,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::OpmThing {view := "Design::viewOpmDecide", kind := (ctor Foundation.Arch::OpmThingKind.object), subject := "Architecture::componentWiseDeferralGuest"})
}

definition{
  name: opmDecide,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::OpmThing,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::OpmThing {view := "Design::viewOpmDecide", kind := (ctor Foundation.Arch::OpmThingKind.process), subject := "Design::processDecide"})
}

definition{
  name: opmParseRequest,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::OpmThing,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::OpmThing {view := "Design::viewOpmDecide", kind := (ctor Foundation.Arch::OpmThingKind.process), subject := "Design::processParseRequest"})
}

definition{
  name: opmJudge,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::OpmThing,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::OpmThing {view := "Design::viewOpmDecide", kind := (ctor Foundation.Arch::OpmThingKind.process), subject := "Design::processJudge"})
}

definition{
  name: opmEncodeAnswer,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::OpmThing,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::OpmThing {view := "Design::viewOpmDecide", kind := (ctor Foundation.Arch::OpmThingKind.process), subject := "Design::processEncodeAnswer"})
}

definition{
  name: opmGuestIdle,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::OpmState,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::OpmState {view := "Design::viewOpmDecide", thing := "Architecture::componentWiseDeferralGuest", state := "Design::stateIdle"})
}

definition{
  name: opmGuestDeciding,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::OpmState,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::OpmState {view := "Design::viewOpmDecide", thing := "Architecture::componentWiseDeferralGuest", state := "Design::stateDeciding"})
}

definition{
  name: opmGuestAgent,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::OpmLink,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::OpmLink {view := "Design::viewOpmDecide", kind := (ctor Foundation.Arch::OpmLinkKind.agent), source := "Architecture::componentWiseDeferralGuest", target := "Design::processDecide"})
}

definition{
  name: opmBrowserInstrument,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::OpmLink,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::OpmLink {view := "Design::viewOpmDecide", kind := (ctor Foundation.Arch::OpmLinkKind.instrument), source := "Architecture::componentBrowser", target := "Design::processParseRequest"})
}

definition{
  name: opmParseInvokesJudge,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::OpmLink,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::OpmLink {view := "Design::viewOpmDecide", kind := (ctor Foundation.Arch::OpmLinkKind.invocation), source := "Design::processParseRequest", target := "Design::processJudge"})
}

definition{
  name: opmJudgeInvokesEncode,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::OpmLink,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::OpmLink {view := "Design::viewOpmDecide", kind := (ctor Foundation.Arch::OpmLinkKind.invocation), source := "Design::processJudge", target := "Design::processEncodeAnswer"})
}

definition{
  name: opmEncodeAffectsBrowser,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::OpmLink,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::OpmLink {view := "Design::viewOpmDecide", kind := (ctor Foundation.Arch::OpmLinkKind.effect), source := "Architecture::componentBrowser", target := "Design::processEncodeAnswer"})
}

definition{
  name: opmZoomParseRequest,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::OpmZoom,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::OpmZoom {view := "Design::viewOpmDecide", process := "Design::processDecide", subprocess := "Design::processParseRequest", order := 0})
}

definition{
  name: opmZoomJudge,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::OpmZoom,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::OpmZoom {view := "Design::viewOpmDecide", process := "Design::processDecide", subprocess := "Design::processJudge", order := 1})
}

definition{
  name: opmZoomEncodeAnswer,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::OpmZoom,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::OpmZoom {view := "Design::viewOpmDecide", process := "Design::processDecide", subprocess := "Design::processEncodeAnswer", order := 2})
}

definition{
  name: umlBrowser,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::UmlComponent,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::UmlComponent {view := "Design::viewUmlComponents", component := "Architecture::componentBrowser"})
}

definition{
  name: umlGitHubPages,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::UmlComponent,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::UmlComponent {view := "Design::viewUmlComponents", component := "Architecture::componentGitHubPages"})
}

definition{
  name: umlH3EREPipeline,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::UmlComponent,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::UmlComponent {view := "Design::viewUmlComponents", component := "Architecture::componentH3EREPipeline"})
}

definition{
  name: umlPrismBuild,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::UmlComponent,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::UmlComponent {view := "Design::viewUmlComponents", component := "Architecture::componentPrismBuild"})
}

definition{
  name: umlSourceRepository,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::UmlComponent,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::UmlComponent {view := "Design::viewUmlComponents", component := "Architecture::componentSourceRepository"})
}

definition{
  name: umlWiseAuthority,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::UmlComponent,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::UmlComponent {view := "Design::viewUmlComponents", component := "Architecture::componentWiseAuthority"})
}

definition{
  name: umlWiseDeferralGuest,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::UmlComponent,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::UmlComponent {view := "Design::viewUmlComponents", component := "Architecture::componentWiseDeferralGuest"})
}

definition{
  name: umlWiseDeferralPage,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::UmlComponent,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::UmlComponent {view := "Design::viewUmlComponents", component := "Architecture::componentWiseDeferralPage"})
}

definition{
  name: umlBrowserToWiseDeferralGuest,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::UmlConnector,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::UmlConnector {view := "Design::viewUmlComponents", edge := "Architecture::edgeBrowserToWiseDeferralGuest"})
}

definition{
  name: umlGitHubPagesToBrowser,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::UmlConnector,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::UmlConnector {view := "Design::viewUmlComponents", edge := "Architecture::edgeGitHubPagesToBrowser"})
}

definition{
  name: umlH3EREPipelineToWiseDeferralGuest,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::UmlConnector,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::UmlConnector {view := "Design::viewUmlComponents", edge := "Architecture::edgeH3EREPipelineToWiseDeferralGuest"})
}

definition{
  name: umlPrismBuildToWiseDeferralGuest,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::UmlConnector,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::UmlConnector {view := "Design::viewUmlComponents", edge := "Architecture::edgePrismBuildToWiseDeferralGuest"})
}

definition{
  name: umlPrismBuildToWiseDeferralPage,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::UmlConnector,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::UmlConnector {view := "Design::viewUmlComponents", edge := "Architecture::edgePrismBuildToWiseDeferralPage"})
}

definition{
  name: umlSourceRepositoryToPrismBuild,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::UmlConnector,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::UmlConnector {view := "Design::viewUmlComponents", edge := "Architecture::edgeSourceRepositoryToPrismBuild"})
}

definition{
  name: umlWiseAuthorityToWiseDeferralGuest,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::UmlConnector,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::UmlConnector {view := "Design::viewUmlComponents", edge := "Architecture::edgeWiseAuthorityToWiseDeferralGuest"})
}

definition{
  name: umlWiseDeferralGuestToBrowser,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::UmlConnector,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::UmlConnector {view := "Design::viewUmlComponents", edge := "Architecture::edgeWiseDeferralGuestToBrowser"})
}

definition{
  name: umlWiseDeferralGuestToH3EREPipeline,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::UmlConnector,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::UmlConnector {view := "Design::viewUmlComponents", edge := "Architecture::edgeWiseDeferralGuestToH3EREPipeline"})
}

definition{
  name: umlWiseDeferralGuestToWiseAuthority,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::UmlConnector,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::UmlConnector {view := "Design::viewUmlComponents", edge := "Architecture::edgeWiseDeferralGuestToWiseAuthority"})
}

definition{
  name: umlWiseDeferralPageToGitHubPages,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::UmlConnector,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::UmlConnector {view := "Design::viewUmlComponents", edge := "Architecture::edgeWiseDeferralPageToGitHubPages"})
}

definition{
  name: seqBrowser,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::UmlLifeline,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::UmlLifeline {view := "Design::viewUmlRequest", component := "Architecture::componentBrowser", order := 0})
}

definition{
  name: seqWiseDeferralGuest,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::UmlLifeline,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::UmlLifeline {view := "Design::viewUmlRequest", component := "Architecture::componentWiseDeferralGuest", order := 1})
}

definition{
  name: seqRequest,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::UmlMessage,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::UmlMessage {view := "Design::viewUmlRequest", kind := (ctor Foundation.Arch::UmlMessageKind.synchronous), order := 0, source := "Architecture::componentBrowser", target := "Architecture::componentWiseDeferralGuest", process := "Design::processDecide"})
}

definition{
  name: seqReply,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::UmlMessage,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::UmlMessage {view := "Design::viewUmlRequest", kind := (ctor Foundation.Arch::UmlMessageKind.reply), order := 1, source := "Architecture::componentWiseDeferralGuest", target := "Architecture::componentBrowser", process := "Design::processDecide"})
}

definition{
  name: stIdle,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::UmlState,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::UmlState {view := "Design::viewUmlStates", state := "Design::stateIdle", initial := true})
}

definition{
  name: stDeciding,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::UmlState,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::UmlState {view := "Design::viewUmlStates", state := "Design::stateDeciding", initial := false})
}

definition{
  name: stRefused,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::UmlState,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::UmlState {view := "Design::viewUmlStates", state := "Design::stateRefused", initial := false})
}

definition{
  name: stAnsweredProceed,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::UmlState,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::UmlState {view := "Design::viewUmlStates", state := "Design::stateAnsweredProceed", initial := false})
}

definition{
  name: stAnsweredDefer,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::UmlState,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::UmlState {view := "Design::viewUmlStates", state := "Design::stateAnsweredDefer", initial := false})
}

definition{
  name: stAnsweredHalt,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::UmlState,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::UmlState {view := "Design::viewUmlStates", state := "Design::stateAnsweredHalt", initial := false})
}

definition{
  name: trAccept,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::UmlTransition,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::UmlTransition {view := "Design::viewUmlStates", order := 0, source := "Design::stateIdle", target := "Design::stateDeciding", trigger := "Design::processParseRequest"})
}

definition{
  name: trRefuse,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::UmlTransition,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::UmlTransition {view := "Design::viewUmlStates", order := 1, source := "Design::stateIdle", target := "Design::stateRefused", trigger := "Design::processParseRequest"})
}

definition{
  name: trRule1,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::UmlTransition,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::UmlTransition {view := "Design::viewUmlStates", order := 2, source := "Design::stateDeciding", target := "Design::stateAnsweredHalt", trigger := "Design::processRule1"})
}

definition{
  name: trRule2,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::UmlTransition,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::UmlTransition {view := "Design::viewUmlStates", order := 3, source := "Design::stateDeciding", target := "Design::stateAnsweredDefer", trigger := "Design::processRule2"})
}

definition{
  name: trRule3,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::UmlTransition,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::UmlTransition {view := "Design::viewUmlStates", order := 4, source := "Design::stateDeciding", target := "Design::stateAnsweredDefer", trigger := "Design::processRule3"})
}

definition{
  name: trRule4,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::UmlTransition,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::UmlTransition {view := "Design::viewUmlStates", order := 5, source := "Design::stateDeciding", target := "Design::stateAnsweredDefer", trigger := "Design::processRule4"})
}

definition{
  name: trOtherwise,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::UmlTransition,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::UmlTransition {view := "Design::viewUmlStates", order := 6, source := "Design::stateDeciding", target := "Design::stateAnsweredProceed", trigger := "Design::processOtherwise"})
}

definition{
  name: trResetProceed,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::UmlTransition,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::UmlTransition {view := "Design::viewUmlStates", order := 7, source := "Design::stateAnsweredProceed", target := "Design::stateIdle", trigger := "Design::processEncodeAnswer"})
}

definition{
  name: trResetDefer,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::UmlTransition,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::UmlTransition {view := "Design::viewUmlStates", order := 8, source := "Design::stateAnsweredDefer", target := "Design::stateIdle", trigger := "Design::processEncodeAnswer"})
}

definition{
  name: trResetHalt,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::UmlTransition,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::UmlTransition {view := "Design::viewUmlStates", order := 9, source := "Design::stateAnsweredHalt", target := "Design::stateIdle", trigger := "Design::processEncodeAnswer"})
}

definition{
  name: trResetRefused,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::UmlTransition,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::UmlTransition {view := "Design::viewUmlStates", order := 10, source := "Design::stateRefused", target := "Design::stateIdle", trigger := "Design::processEncodeAnswer"})
}
\end{semanticmodule}
\end{lexlean}
app/src/Features.lex.tex 151 lines
\begin{lexlean}{Features}
\useglossary{lexlean.std.bool@1.2.0}
\useglossary{lexlean.std.nat@1.2.0}
\useglossary{prism.arch@1.0.0}
\importmodule{CirisDeferral}
\importmodule{Architecture}
\importmodule{Foundation.Arch}
\title{feature}
\begin{semanticmodule}
definition{
  name: acceptINV001,
  parameters: [],
  result: String,
  body: "CirisDeferralProofs::inv001Holds"
}

definition{
  name: acceptINV002,
  parameters: [],
  result: String,
  body: "CirisDeferralProofs::inv002Holds"
}

definition{
  name: acceptINV003,
  parameters: [],
  result: String,
  body: "CirisDeferralProofs::inv003Holds"
}

definition{
  name: acceptINV004,
  parameters: [],
  result: String,
  body: "CirisDeferralProofs::inv004Holds"
}

definition{
  name: acceptINV005,
  parameters: [],
  result: String,
  body: "CirisDeferralProofs::inv005Holds"
}

definition{
  name: featureRule1,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Feature,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Feature {statement := "When seats is at least 2, the answer is halt.", calls := (cons "CirisDeferral::rule1" (cons "CirisDeferral::judge" (nil String))), acceptance := (cons "CirisDeferral::application" (nil String))})
}

definition{
  name: featureRule2,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Feature,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Feature {statement := "When conscience is vetoed, the answer is defer.", calls := (cons "CirisDeferral::rule2" (cons "CirisDeferral::judge" (nil String))), acceptance := (cons "CirisDeferral::application" (nil String))})
}

definition{
  name: featureRule3,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Feature,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Feature {statement := "When keff is below 4, the answer is defer.", calls := (cons "CirisDeferral::rule3" (cons "CirisDeferral::judge" (nil String))), acceptance := (cons "CirisDeferral::application" (nil String))})
}

definition{
  name: featureRule4,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Feature,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Feature {statement := "When margin is below 15, the answer is defer.", calls := (cons "CirisDeferral::rule4" (cons "CirisDeferral::judge" (nil String))), acceptance := (cons "CirisDeferral::application" (nil String))})
}

definition{
  name: featureOtherwise,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Feature,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Feature {statement := "When no rule matches, the answer is proceed.", calls := (cons "CirisDeferral::judge" (nil String)), acceptance := (cons "CirisDeferral::application" (nil String))})
}

definition{
  name: featureRefuseMalformed,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Feature,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Feature {statement := "A request that is not margin, keff, conscience, seats in order, separated by single spaces, or is over 112 bytes, is answered invalid.", calls := (cons "CirisDeferral::dispatch" (cons "CirisDeferral::decodeField1" (nil String))), acceptance := (cons "CirisDeferral::application" (nil String))})
}

definition{
  name: featureINV001,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Feature,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Feature {statement := "It never answers proceed when conscience is vetoed.", calls := (cons "CirisDeferral::judge" (nil String)), acceptance := (cons "Features::acceptINV001" (nil String))})
}

definition{
  name: featureINV002,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Feature,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Feature {statement := "It never answers proceed when keff is below 4.", calls := (cons "CirisDeferral::judge" (nil String)), acceptance := (cons "Features::acceptINV002" (nil String))})
}

definition{
  name: featureINV003,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Feature,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Feature {statement := "It never answers proceed when margin is below 15.", calls := (cons "CirisDeferral::judge" (nil String)), acceptance := (cons "Features::acceptINV003" (nil String))})
}

definition{
  name: featureINV004,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Feature,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Feature {statement := "It always answers halt when seats is at least 2.", calls := (cons "CirisDeferral::judge" (nil String)), acceptance := (cons "Features::acceptINV004" (nil String))})
}

definition{
  name: featureINV005,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Feature,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Feature {statement := "It never answers halt when seats is below 2.", calls := (cons "CirisDeferral::judge" (nil String)), acceptance := (cons "Features::acceptINV005" (nil String))})
}

definition{
  name: journeyAffectedPerson,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Journey,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Journey {actor := "Architecture::stakeholderAffectedPerson", steps := (cons "Features::featureINV001" (cons "Features::featureINV002" (cons "Features::featureINV003" (nil String))))})
}

definition{
  name: journeyAgentOperator,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Journey,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Journey {actor := "Architecture::stakeholderAgentOperator", steps := (cons "Features::featureRule2" (cons "Features::featureRule3" (cons "Features::featureRule4" (cons "Features::featureOtherwise" (nil String)))))})
}

definition{
  name: journeyVerifier,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Journey,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Journey {actor := "Architecture::stakeholderVerifier", steps := (cons "Features::featureRefuseMalformed" (cons "Features::featureINV001" (cons "Features::featureINV002" (cons "Features::featureINV003" (cons "Features::featureINV004" (cons "Features::featureINV005" (nil String)))))))})
}

definition{
  name: journeyWiseAuthority,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Arch::Journey,
  body: (record Foundation.Arch::Journey {actor := "Architecture::stakeholderWiseAuthority", steps := (cons "Features::featureRule1" (cons "Features::featureINV004" (cons "Features::featureINV005" (nil String))))})
}
\end{semanticmodule}
\end{lexlean}
app/src/Quality.lex.tex 361 lines
\begin{lexlean}{Quality}
\useglossary{lexlean.std.bool@1.2.0}
\useglossary{lexlean.std.nat@1.2.0}
\useglossary{prism.arch@1.0.0}
\useglossary{prism.qual@1.0.0}
\importmodule{Foundation.Qual}
\title{quality measure}
\begin{semanticmodule}
structure{
  name: Named,
  type_parameters: [],
  parameters: [],
  fields: [{name: index, type: Nat}, {name: name, type: String}, {name: text, type: String}]
}

definition{
  name: characteristicFunctionalSuitability,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Qual::ProductQualityCharacteristic,
  body: (record Foundation.Qual::ProductQualityCharacteristic {index := 0})
}

definition{
  name: characteristicPerformanceEfficiency,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Qual::ProductQualityCharacteristic,
  body: (record Foundation.Qual::ProductQualityCharacteristic {index := 1})
}

definition{
  name: characteristicReliability,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Qual::ProductQualityCharacteristic,
  body: (record Foundation.Qual::ProductQualityCharacteristic {index := 2})
}

definition{
  name: characteristicSafety,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Qual::ProductQualityCharacteristic,
  body: (record Foundation.Qual::ProductQualityCharacteristic {index := 3})
}

definition{
  name: characteristicSecurity,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Qual::ProductQualityCharacteristic,
  body: (record Foundation.Qual::ProductQualityCharacteristic {index := 4})
}

definition{
  name: subcharacteristicFailSafe,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Qual::QualitySubcharacteristic,
  body: (record Foundation.Qual::QualitySubcharacteristic {index := 0, characteristicIndex := 3})
}

definition{
  name: subcharacteristicFaultlessness,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Qual::QualitySubcharacteristic,
  body: (record Foundation.Qual::QualitySubcharacteristic {index := 1, characteristicIndex := 2})
}

definition{
  name: subcharacteristicFunctionalCompleteness,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Qual::QualitySubcharacteristic,
  body: (record Foundation.Qual::QualitySubcharacteristic {index := 2, characteristicIndex := 0})
}

definition{
  name: subcharacteristicFunctionalCorrectness,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Qual::QualitySubcharacteristic,
  body: (record Foundation.Qual::QualitySubcharacteristic {index := 3, characteristicIndex := 0})
}

definition{
  name: subcharacteristicIntegrity,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Qual::QualitySubcharacteristic,
  body: (record Foundation.Qual::QualitySubcharacteristic {index := 4, characteristicIndex := 4})
}

definition{
  name: subcharacteristicResourceUtilization,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Qual::QualitySubcharacteristic,
  body: (record Foundation.Qual::QualitySubcharacteristic {index := 5, characteristicIndex := 1})
}

definition{
  name: subcharacteristicTimeBehaviour,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Qual::QualitySubcharacteristic,
  body: (record Foundation.Qual::QualitySubcharacteristic {index := 6, characteristicIndex := 1})
}

definition{
  name: requirementBoundedAllocation,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Qual::QualityRequirement,
  body: (record Foundation.Qual::QualityRequirement {index := 0, subcharacteristicIndex := 5})
}

definition{
  name: requirementBoundedRequest,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Qual::QualityRequirement,
  body: (record Foundation.Qual::QualityRequirement {index := 1, subcharacteristicIndex := 6})
}

definition{
  name: requirementEveryPropertyProved,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Qual::QualityRequirement,
  body: (record Foundation.Qual::QualityRequirement {index := 2, subcharacteristicIndex := 4})
}

definition{
  name: requirementEveryRequestAnswered,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Qual::QualityRequirement,
  body: (record Foundation.Qual::QualityRequirement {index := 3, subcharacteristicIndex := 2})
}

definition{
  name: requirementEveryVectorReplays,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Qual::QualityRequirement,
  body: (record Foundation.Qual::QualityRequirement {index := 4, subcharacteristicIndex := 1})
}

definition{
  name: requirementExamplesAnsweredAsStated,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Qual::QualityRequirement,
  body: (record Foundation.Qual::QualityRequirement {index := 5, subcharacteristicIndex := 3})
}

definition{
  name: requirementUncertaintyDefers,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Qual::QualityRequirement,
  body: (record Foundation.Qual::QualityRequirement {index := 6, subcharacteristicIndex := 0})
}

definition{
  name: measureAutonomousAnswersUnderUncertainty,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Qual::QualityMeasure,
  body: (record Foundation.Qual::QualityMeasure {index := 0, requirementIndex := 6, threshold := 0})
}

definition{
  name: measureExampleMismatches,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Qual::QualityMeasure,
  body: (record Foundation.Qual::QualityMeasure {index := 1, requirementIndex := 5, threshold := 0})
}

definition{
  name: measureFailedVectors,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Qual::QualityMeasure,
  body: (record Foundation.Qual::QualityMeasure {index := 2, requirementIndex := 4, threshold := 0})
}

definition{
  name: measureGuestAllocationBytes,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Qual::QualityMeasure,
  body: (record Foundation.Qual::QualityMeasure {index := 3, requirementIndex := 0, threshold := 224})
}

definition{
  name: measureRequestBytesRead,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Qual::QualityMeasure,
  body: (record Foundation.Qual::QualityMeasure {index := 4, requirementIndex := 1, threshold := 112})
}

definition{
  name: measureUnansweredRequests,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Qual::QualityMeasure,
  body: (record Foundation.Qual::QualityMeasure {index := 5, requirementIndex := 3, threshold := 0})
}

definition{
  name: measureUnprovedProperties,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Qual::QualityMeasure,
  body: (record Foundation.Qual::QualityMeasure {index := 6, requirementIndex := 2, threshold := 0})
}

definition{
  name: characteristicNames,
  parameters: [],
  result: (List Named),
  body: (cons (record Named {index := 0, name := "Functional suitability", text := "Functional suitability, as ISO/IEC 25010:2023 defines it, for Wise deferral."}) (cons (record Named {index := 1, name := "Performance efficiency", text := "Performance efficiency, as ISO/IEC 25010:2023 defines it, for Wise deferral."}) (cons (record Named {index := 2, name := "Reliability", text := "Reliability, as ISO/IEC 25010:2023 defines it, for Wise deferral."}) (cons (record Named {index := 3, name := "Safety", text := "Safety, as ISO/IEC 25010:2023 defines it, for Wise deferral."}) (cons (record Named {index := 4, name := "Security", text := "Security, as ISO/IEC 25010:2023 defines it, for Wise deferral."}) (nil Named))))))
}

definition{
  name: subcharacteristicNames,
  parameters: [],
  result: (List Named),
  body: (cons (record Named {index := 0, name := "Fail safe", text := "Safety: Fail safe."}) (cons (record Named {index := 1, name := "Faultlessness", text := "Reliability: Faultlessness."}) (cons (record Named {index := 2, name := "Functional completeness", text := "Functional suitability: Functional completeness."}) (cons (record Named {index := 3, name := "Functional correctness", text := "Functional suitability: Functional correctness."}) (cons (record Named {index := 4, name := "Integrity", text := "Security: Integrity."}) (cons (record Named {index := 5, name := "Resource utilization", text := "Performance efficiency: Resource utilization."}) (cons (record Named {index := 6, name := "Time behaviour", text := "Performance efficiency: Time behaviour."}) (nil Named))))))))
}

definition{
  name: requirementNames,
  parameters: [],
  result: (List Named),
  body: (cons (record Named {index := 0, name := "Bounded allocation", text := "The guest allocates at most 224 bytes for one request."}) (cons (record Named {index := 1, name := "Bounded request", text := "A request over 112 bytes is refused before any field is read."}) (cons (record Named {index := 2, name := "Every property proved", text := "All 5 properties are theorems the Lean kernel checks."}) (cons (record Named {index := 3, name := "Every request answered", text := "Every request gets an answer: a rule, proceed otherwise, or invalid."}) (cons (record Named {index := 4, name := "Every vector replays", text := "All 52 acceptance vectors replay in the compiled guest, the shortest 0 bytes long."}) (cons (record Named {index := 5, name := "Examples answered as stated", text := "Every one of the 6 examples of the spec is answered as it states."}) (cons (record Named {index := 6, name := "Uncertainty defers", text := "Every request with a vetoed conscience, k_eff below 4 or a margin below 15 is answered defer or halt."}) (nil Named))))))))
}

definition{
  name: measureNames,
  parameters: [],
  result: (List Named),
  body: (cons (record Named {index := 0, name := "Autonomous answers under uncertainty", text := "Requests with a veto, low diversity or low margin that are answered proceed."}) (cons (record Named {index := 1, name := "Example mismatches", text := "Examples the guest answers otherwise than they state."}) (cons (record Named {index := 2, name := "Failed vectors", text := "Acceptance vectors whose replay differs from the model."}) (cons (record Named {index := 3, name := "Guest allocation bytes", text := "Most bytes the guest allocates for one request."}) (cons (record Named {index := 4, name := "Request bytes read", text := "Longest request the guest decodes, in bytes."}) (cons (record Named {index := 5, name := "Unanswered requests", text := "Acceptance vectors the guest does not answer."}) (cons (record Named {index := 6, name := "Unproved properties", text := "Properties of the spec without a checked theorem."}) (nil Named))))))))
}

definition{
  name: subcharacteristicRecords,
  parameters: [],
  result: (List Foundation.Qual::QualitySubcharacteristic),
  body: (cons (subcharacteristicFailSafe) (cons (subcharacteristicFaultlessness) (cons (subcharacteristicFunctionalCompleteness) (cons (subcharacteristicFunctionalCorrectness) (cons (subcharacteristicIntegrity) (cons (subcharacteristicResourceUtilization) (cons (subcharacteristicTimeBehaviour) (nil Foundation.Qual::QualitySubcharacteristic))))))))
}

definition{
  name: requirementRecords,
  parameters: [],
  result: (List Foundation.Qual::QualityRequirement),
  body: (cons (requirementBoundedAllocation) (cons (requirementBoundedRequest) (cons (requirementEveryPropertyProved) (cons (requirementEveryRequestAnswered) (cons (requirementEveryVectorReplays) (cons (requirementExamplesAnsweredAsStated) (cons (requirementUncertaintyDefers) (nil Foundation.Qual::QualityRequirement))))))))
}

definition{
  name: measureRecords,
  parameters: [],
  result: (List Foundation.Qual::QualityMeasure),
  body: (cons (measureAutonomousAnswersUnderUncertainty) (cons (measureExampleMismatches) (cons (measureFailedVectors) (cons (measureGuestAllocationBytes) (cons (measureRequestBytesRead) (cons (measureUnansweredRequests) (cons (measureUnprovedProperties) (nil Foundation.Qual::QualityMeasure))))))))
}

definition{
  name: namesNumbered,
  parameters: [position : Nat, names : (List Named)],
  result: Bool,
  body: (match names
    | List.nil => true
    | List.cons item rest => (((project item index) =? position) && (namesNumbered (position + 1) rest))),
  recursive_argument: names
}

definition{
  name: parentsKnown,
  parameters: [count : Nat, records : (List Foundation.Qual::QualitySubcharacteristic)],
  result: Bool,
  body: (match records
    | List.nil => true
    | List.cons item rest => (((project item characteristicIndex) <? count) && (parentsKnown count rest))),
  recursive_argument: records
}

definition{
  name: requirementsKnown,
  parameters: [count : Nat, records : (List Foundation.Qual::QualityRequirement)],
  result: Bool,
  body: (match records
    | List.nil => true
    | List.cons item rest => (((project item subcharacteristicIndex) <? count) && (requirementsKnown count rest))),
  recursive_argument: records
}

definition{
  name: measuresKnown,
  parameters: [count : Nat, records : (List Foundation.Qual::QualityMeasure)],
  result: Bool,
  body: (match records
    | List.nil => true
    | List.cons item rest => (((project item requirementIndex) <? count) && (measuresKnown count rest))),
  recursive_argument: records
}

definition{
  name: thresholdOf,
  parameters: [wanted : Nat, records : (List Foundation.Qual::QualityMeasure)],
  result: Nat,
  body: (match records
    | List.nil => 0
    | List.cons head rest => (if ((project head index) =? wanted) then (project head threshold) else (thresholdOf wanted rest))),
  recursive_argument: records
}

definition{
  name: qualityValid,
  parameters: [],
  result: Bool,
  body: ((namesNumbered 0 (characteristicNames)) && ((namesNumbered 0 (subcharacteristicNames)) && ((namesNumbered 0 (requirementNames)) && ((namesNumbered 0 (measureNames)) && ((parentsKnown 5 (subcharacteristicRecords)) && ((requirementsKnown 7 (requirementRecords)) && (measuresKnown 7 (measureRecords))))))))
}

theorem{
  name: qualityModelHolds,
  parameters: [],
  statement: ((qualityValid) = true),
  proof: decide{}
}

theorem{
  name: measureAutonomousAnswersUnderUncertaintyThreshold,
  parameters: [],
  statement: ((thresholdOf 0 (measureRecords)) = 0),
  proof: decide{}
}

theorem{
  name: measureExampleMismatchesThreshold,
  parameters: [],
  statement: ((thresholdOf 1 (measureRecords)) = 0),
  proof: decide{}
}

theorem{
  name: measureFailedVectorsThreshold,
  parameters: [],
  statement: ((thresholdOf 2 (measureRecords)) = 0),
  proof: decide{}
}

theorem{
  name: measureGuestAllocationBytesThreshold,
  parameters: [],
  statement: ((thresholdOf 3 (measureRecords)) = 224),
  proof: decide{}
}

theorem{
  name: measureRequestBytesReadThreshold,
  parameters: [],
  statement: ((thresholdOf 4 (measureRecords)) = 112),
  proof: decide{}
}

theorem{
  name: measureUnansweredRequestsThreshold,
  parameters: [],
  statement: ((thresholdOf 5 (measureRecords)) = 0),
  proof: decide{}
}

theorem{
  name: measureUnprovedPropertiesThreshold,
  parameters: [],
  statement: ((thresholdOf 6 (measureRecords)) = 0),
  proof: decide{}
}
\end{semanticmodule}
\end{lexlean}
app/src/Security.lex.tex 635 lines
\begin{lexlean}{Security}
\useglossary{lexlean.std.bool@1.2.0}
\useglossary{lexlean.std.nat@1.2.0}
\useglossary{prism.arch@1.0.0}
\useglossary{prism.sec@1.0.0}
\importmodule{Foundation.Sec}
\importmodule{Production.ThreatModel}
\importmodule{Architecture}
\title{security threat}
\begin{semanticmodule}
definition{
  name: assetAnswer,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::Asset,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::Asset {index := 0, componentIndex := 6})
}

definition{
  name: assetModelSource,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::Asset,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::Asset {index := 1, componentIndex := 4})
}

definition{
  name: assetPublishedHolo,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::Asset,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::Asset {index := 2, componentIndex := 7})
}

definition{
  name: assetRequestBytes,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::Asset,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::Asset {index := 3, componentIndex := 6})
}

definition{
  name: threatAnswerThatBreaksINV001,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::Threat,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::Threat {index := 0})
}

definition{
  name: threatAnswerThatBreaksINV002,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::Threat,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::Threat {index := 1})
}

definition{
  name: threatAnswerThatBreaksINV003,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::Threat,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::Threat {index := 2})
}

definition{
  name: threatAnswerThatBreaksINV004,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::Threat,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::Threat {index := 3})
}

definition{
  name: threatAnswerThatBreaksINV005,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::Threat,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::Threat {index := 4})
}

definition{
  name: threatConscienceResultSpoofed,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::Threat,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::Threat {index := 5})
}

definition{
  name: threatGrantedCapability,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::Threat,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::Threat {index := 6})
}

definition{
  name: threatMalformedRequest,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::Threat,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::Threat {index := 7})
}

definition{
  name: threatOversizedRequest,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::Threat,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::Threat {index := 8})
}

definition{
  name: threatSingleSeatHalt,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::Threat,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::Threat {index := 9})
}

definition{
  name: threatSubstitutedHolo,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::Threat,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::Threat {index := 10})
}

definition{
  name: threatSubstitutedHost,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::Threat,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::Threat {index := 11})
}

definition{
  name: threatSycophanticMonoculture,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::Threat,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::Threat {index := 12})
}

definition{
  name: threatTamperedModel,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::Threat,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::Threat {index := 13})
}

definition{
  name: riskAnswerThatBreaksINV001,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::Risk,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::Risk {index := 0, assetIndex := 0, threatIndex := 0, likelihood := (ctor Foundation.Sec::Likelihood.medium), impact := (ctor Foundation.Sec::Impact.critical)})
}

definition{
  name: riskAnswerThatBreaksINV002,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::Risk,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::Risk {index := 1, assetIndex := 0, threatIndex := 1, likelihood := (ctor Foundation.Sec::Likelihood.medium), impact := (ctor Foundation.Sec::Impact.critical)})
}

definition{
  name: riskAnswerThatBreaksINV003,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::Risk,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::Risk {index := 2, assetIndex := 0, threatIndex := 2, likelihood := (ctor Foundation.Sec::Likelihood.medium), impact := (ctor Foundation.Sec::Impact.critical)})
}

definition{
  name: riskAnswerThatBreaksINV004,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::Risk,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::Risk {index := 3, assetIndex := 0, threatIndex := 3, likelihood := (ctor Foundation.Sec::Likelihood.medium), impact := (ctor Foundation.Sec::Impact.critical)})
}

definition{
  name: riskAnswerThatBreaksINV005,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::Risk,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::Risk {index := 4, assetIndex := 0, threatIndex := 4, likelihood := (ctor Foundation.Sec::Likelihood.medium), impact := (ctor Foundation.Sec::Impact.critical)})
}

definition{
  name: riskConscienceResultSpoofed,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::Risk,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::Risk {index := 5, assetIndex := 3, threatIndex := 5, likelihood := (ctor Foundation.Sec::Likelihood.medium), impact := (ctor Foundation.Sec::Impact.major)})
}

definition{
  name: riskGrantedCapability,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::Risk,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::Risk {index := 6, assetIndex := 0, threatIndex := 6, likelihood := (ctor Foundation.Sec::Likelihood.low), impact := (ctor Foundation.Sec::Impact.major)})
}

definition{
  name: riskMalformedRequest,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::Risk,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::Risk {index := 7, assetIndex := 3, threatIndex := 7, likelihood := (ctor Foundation.Sec::Likelihood.high), impact := (ctor Foundation.Sec::Impact.major)})
}

definition{
  name: riskOversizedRequest,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::Risk,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::Risk {index := 8, assetIndex := 3, threatIndex := 8, likelihood := (ctor Foundation.Sec::Likelihood.medium), impact := (ctor Foundation.Sec::Impact.minor)})
}

definition{
  name: riskSingleSeatHalt,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::Risk,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::Risk {index := 9, assetIndex := 0, threatIndex := 9, likelihood := (ctor Foundation.Sec::Likelihood.low), impact := (ctor Foundation.Sec::Impact.major)})
}

definition{
  name: riskSubstitutedHolo,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::Risk,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::Risk {index := 10, assetIndex := 2, threatIndex := 10, likelihood := (ctor Foundation.Sec::Likelihood.low), impact := (ctor Foundation.Sec::Impact.critical)})
}

definition{
  name: riskSubstitutedHost,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::Risk,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::Risk {index := 11, assetIndex := 2, threatIndex := 11, likelihood := (ctor Foundation.Sec::Likelihood.low), impact := (ctor Foundation.Sec::Impact.critical)})
}

definition{
  name: riskSycophanticMonoculture,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::Risk,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::Risk {index := 12, assetIndex := 0, threatIndex := 12, likelihood := (ctor Foundation.Sec::Likelihood.medium), impact := (ctor Foundation.Sec::Impact.critical)})
}

definition{
  name: riskTamperedModel,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::Risk,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::Risk {index := 13, assetIndex := 1, threatIndex := 13, likelihood := (ctor Foundation.Sec::Likelihood.low), impact := (ctor Foundation.Sec::Impact.major)})
}

definition{
  name: controlBoundedRequest,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::ApplicationSecurityControl,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::ApplicationSecurityControl {index := 0, riskIndex := 8})
}

definition{
  name: controlDiversityFloor,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::ApplicationSecurityControl,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::ApplicationSecurityControl {index := 1, riskIndex := 12})
}

definition{
  name: controlFingerprintAndProvenance,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::ApplicationSecurityControl,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::ApplicationSecurityControl {index := 2, riskIndex := 10})
}

definition{
  name: controlNoCapabilityGranted,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::ApplicationSecurityControl,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::ApplicationSecurityControl {index := 3, riskIndex := 6})
}

definition{
  name: controlProofOfINV001,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::ApplicationSecurityControl,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::ApplicationSecurityControl {index := 4, riskIndex := 0})
}

definition{
  name: controlProofOfINV002,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::ApplicationSecurityControl,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::ApplicationSecurityControl {index := 5, riskIndex := 1})
}

definition{
  name: controlProofOfINV003,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::ApplicationSecurityControl,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::ApplicationSecurityControl {index := 6, riskIndex := 2})
}

definition{
  name: controlProofOfINV004,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::ApplicationSecurityControl,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::ApplicationSecurityControl {index := 7, riskIndex := 3})
}

definition{
  name: controlProofOfINV005,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::ApplicationSecurityControl,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::ApplicationSecurityControl {index := 8, riskIndex := 4})
}

definition{
  name: controlQuorumProved,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::ApplicationSecurityControl,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::ApplicationSecurityControl {index := 9, riskIndex := 9})
}

definition{
  name: controlRegeneratedFromThePrompt,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::ApplicationSecurityControl,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::ApplicationSecurityControl {index := 10, riskIndex := 13})
}

definition{
  name: controlStrictDecoder,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.Sec::ApplicationSecurityControl,
  body: (record Foundation.Sec::ApplicationSecurityControl {index := 11, riskIndex := 7})
}

definition{
  name: controlSet,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ControlSet,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ControlSet {title := "Wise deferral security controls", text := "Wise deferral answers one request with one answer in a Core-Wasm guest granted no capability. Decide whether an agent proceeds, defers to a wise authority, or is halted, from its confidence margin, the diversity of its perspectives, the conscience gate and the Wise Authority seats that signed a halt.", version := "0.1.0", lastModified := "2026-11-12T18:44:38Z"})
}

definition{
  name: modeledAssetAnswer,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ModeledAsset,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ModeledAsset {asset := "Security::assetAnswer", name := "Answer", text := "The answer the guest returns: one of proceed, defer, halt, or invalid."})
}

definition{
  name: modeledAssetModelSource,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ModeledAsset,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ModeledAsset {asset := "Security::assetModelSource", name := "Model source", text := "The prompt, the spec and the LexLean model in the repository, from which the holo is built."})
}

definition{
  name: modeledAssetPublishedHolo,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ModeledAsset,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ModeledAsset {asset := "Security::assetPublishedHolo", name := "Published holo", text := "The holo and page the Pages workflow publishes, with its fingerprint and signed provenance."})
}

definition{
  name: modeledAssetRequestBytes,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ModeledAsset,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ModeledAsset {asset := "Security::assetRequestBytes", name := "Request bytes", text := "The bytes a caller sends, at most 112 of them."})
}

definition{
  name: modeledThreatAnswerThatBreaksINV001,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ModeledThreat,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ModeledThreat {threat := "Security::threatAnswerThatBreaksINV001", name := "Answer that breaks INV-001", text := "The guest answers proceed although conscience is vetoed, which matters because the conscience gate is a non-bypassable final veto.", category := (ctor Production.ThreatModel::Stride.repudiation)})
}

definition{
  name: modeledThreatAnswerThatBreaksINV002,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ModeledThreat,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ModeledThreat {threat := "Security::threatAnswerThatBreaksINV002", name := "Answer that breaks INV-002", text := "The guest answers proceed although keff is below 4, which matters because a monoculture of perspectives never acts alone.", category := (ctor Production.ThreatModel::Stride.repudiation)})
}

definition{
  name: modeledThreatAnswerThatBreaksINV003,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ModeledThreat,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ModeledThreat {threat := "Security::threatAnswerThatBreaksINV003", name := "Answer that breaks INV-003", text := "The guest answers proceed although margin is below 15, which matters because the agent does not act on a near tie.", category := (ctor Production.ThreatModel::Stride.repudiation)})
}

definition{
  name: modeledThreatAnswerThatBreaksINV004,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ModeledThreat,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ModeledThreat {threat := "Security::threatAnswerThatBreaksINV004", name := "Answer that breaks INV-004", text := "The guest answers halt not when seats is at least 2, which matters because a 2-of-3 Yubikey quorum always halts.", category := (ctor Production.ThreatModel::Stride.repudiation)})
}

definition{
  name: modeledThreatAnswerThatBreaksINV005,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ModeledThreat,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ModeledThreat {threat := "Security::threatAnswerThatBreaksINV005", name := "Answer that breaks INV-005", text := "The guest answers halt although seats is below 2, which matters because yubikeySingleSeatCannotHalt: one seat alone cannot halt.", category := (ctor Production.ThreatModel::Stride.repudiation)})
}

definition{
  name: modeledThreatConscienceResultSpoofed,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ModeledThreat,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ModeledThreat {threat := "Security::threatConscienceResultSpoofed", name := "Conscience result spoofed", text := "A caller reports that the conscience gate passed when it vetoed, to make the agent act.", category := (ctor Production.ThreatModel::Stride.spoofing)})
}

definition{
  name: modeledThreatGrantedCapability,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ModeledThreat,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ModeledThreat {threat := "Security::threatGrantedCapability", name := "Granted capability", text := "The guest reads, stores or sends data beyond the request it answers.", category := (ctor Production.ThreatModel::Stride.informationDisclosure)})
}

definition{
  name: modeledThreatMalformedRequest,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ModeledThreat,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ModeledThreat {threat := "Security::threatMalformedRequest", name := "Malformed request", text := "A request with a missing, extra, unknown or badly written field is answered as if it were well formed.", category := (ctor Production.ThreatModel::Stride.tampering)})
}

definition{
  name: modeledThreatOversizedRequest,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ModeledThreat,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ModeledThreat {threat := "Security::threatOversizedRequest", name := "Oversized request", text := "A request longer than 112 bytes makes the guest parse or allocate without bound.", category := (ctor Production.ThreatModel::Stride.denialOfService)})
}

definition{
  name: modeledThreatSingleSeatHalt,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ModeledThreat,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ModeledThreat {threat := "Security::threatSingleSeatHalt", name := "Single-seat halt", text := "One Wise Authority seat halts the agent alone, or impersonates a quorum.", category := (ctor Production.ThreatModel::Stride.elevationOfPrivilege)})
}

definition{
  name: modeledThreatSubstitutedHolo,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ModeledThreat,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ModeledThreat {threat := "Security::threatSubstitutedHolo", name := "Substituted holo", text := "A holo other than the one the build verified is served under the app address.", category := (ctor Production.ThreatModel::Stride.spoofing)})
}

definition{
  name: modeledThreatSubstitutedHost,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ModeledThreat,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ModeledThreat {threat := "Security::threatSubstitutedHost", name := "Substituted host", text := "Something other than the repository Pages workflow serves pages under its address.", category := (ctor Production.ThreatModel::Stride.spoofing)})
}

definition{
  name: modeledThreatSycophanticMonoculture,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ModeledThreat,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ModeledThreat {threat := "Security::threatSycophanticMonoculture", name := "Sycophantic monoculture", text := "The agent acts when its perspectives are not independent, so one view decides.", category := (ctor Production.ThreatModel::Stride.tampering)})
}

definition{
  name: modeledThreatTamperedModel,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ModeledThreat,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ModeledThreat {threat := "Security::threatTamperedModel", name := "Tampered model", text := "The model the holo is built from differs from the reviewed prompt and spec.", category := (ctor Production.ThreatModel::Stride.tampering)})
}

definition{
  name: modeledControlBoundedRequest,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ModeledControl,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ModeledControl {control := "Security::controlBoundedRequest", name := "Bounded request", text := "dispatch answers invalid for a request over 112 bytes before reading a field, and the guest allocates at most 224.", evidence := (cons (record Production.ThreatModel::Evidence {kind := (ctor Production.ThreatModel::EvidenceKind.gate), reference := "acceptance vectors at the request bound, one byte over it, and at the guest allocation bound, replayed by prismpm verify"}) (nil Production.ThreatModel::Evidence))})
}

definition{
  name: modeledControlDiversityFloor,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ModeledControl,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ModeledControl {control := "Security::controlDiversityFloor", name := "Diversity floor", text := "Below k_eff 4 the agent defers, proved for every request.", evidence := (cons (record Production.ThreatModel::Evidence {kind := (ctor Production.ThreatModel::EvidenceKind.proof), reference := "CirisDeferralProofs::inv002Holds"}) (cons (record Production.ThreatModel::Evidence {kind := (ctor Production.ThreatModel::EvidenceKind.review), reference := "src/Coherence.lex.tex Kish k_eff verifier"}) (nil Production.ThreatModel::Evidence)))})
}

definition{
  name: modeledControlFingerprintAndProvenance,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ModeledControl,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ModeledControl {control := "Security::controlFingerprintAndProvenance", name := "Fingerprint and provenance", text := "The page verifies the holo digests before it runs, and the build signs its provenance as the repository workflow.", evidence := (cons (record Production.ThreatModel::Evidence {kind := (ctor Production.ThreatModel::EvidenceKind.gate), reference := "actions/attest-build-provenance in the pages workflow"}) (cons (record Production.ThreatModel::Evidence {kind := (ctor Production.ThreatModel::EvidenceKind.gate), reference := "prism-code check of the holo identities in the page"}) (nil Production.ThreatModel::Evidence)))})
}

definition{
  name: modeledControlNoCapabilityGranted,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ModeledControl,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ModeledControl {control := "Security::controlNoCapabilityGranted", name := "No capability granted", text := "prism.toml grants the holo nothing and the model declares capabilitiesEmpty, so a guest import of any host capability is refused.", evidence := (cons (record Production.ThreatModel::Evidence {kind := (ctor Production.ThreatModel::EvidenceKind.gate), reference := "prism-code check refuses an ungranted guest import"}) (nil Production.ThreatModel::Evidence))})
}

definition{
  name: modeledControlProofOfINV001,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ModeledControl,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ModeledControl {control := "Security::controlProofOfINV001", name := "Proof of INV-001", text := "It never answers proceed when conscience is vetoed. The Lean kernel proves it for every request.", evidence := (cons (record Production.ThreatModel::Evidence {kind := (ctor Production.ThreatModel::EvidenceKind.proof), reference := "CirisDeferralProofs::inv001Holds"}) (nil Production.ThreatModel::Evidence))})
}

definition{
  name: modeledControlProofOfINV002,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ModeledControl,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ModeledControl {control := "Security::controlProofOfINV002", name := "Proof of INV-002", text := "It never answers proceed when keff is below 4. The Lean kernel proves it for every request.", evidence := (cons (record Production.ThreatModel::Evidence {kind := (ctor Production.ThreatModel::EvidenceKind.proof), reference := "CirisDeferralProofs::inv002Holds"}) (nil Production.ThreatModel::Evidence))})
}

definition{
  name: modeledControlProofOfINV003,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ModeledControl,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ModeledControl {control := "Security::controlProofOfINV003", name := "Proof of INV-003", text := "It never answers proceed when margin is below 15. The Lean kernel proves it for every request.", evidence := (cons (record Production.ThreatModel::Evidence {kind := (ctor Production.ThreatModel::EvidenceKind.proof), reference := "CirisDeferralProofs::inv003Holds"}) (nil Production.ThreatModel::Evidence))})
}

definition{
  name: modeledControlProofOfINV004,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ModeledControl,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ModeledControl {control := "Security::controlProofOfINV004", name := "Proof of INV-004", text := "It always answers halt when seats is at least 2. The Lean kernel proves it for every request.", evidence := (cons (record Production.ThreatModel::Evidence {kind := (ctor Production.ThreatModel::EvidenceKind.proof), reference := "CirisDeferralProofs::inv004Holds"}) (nil Production.ThreatModel::Evidence))})
}

definition{
  name: modeledControlProofOfINV005,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ModeledControl,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ModeledControl {control := "Security::controlProofOfINV005", name := "Proof of INV-005", text := "It never answers halt when seats is below 2. The Lean kernel proves it for every request.", evidence := (cons (record Production.ThreatModel::Evidence {kind := (ctor Production.ThreatModel::EvidenceKind.proof), reference := "CirisDeferralProofs::inv005Holds"}) (nil Production.ThreatModel::Evidence))})
}

definition{
  name: modeledControlQuorumProved,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ModeledControl,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ModeledControl {control := "Security::controlQuorumProved", name := "Quorum proved", text := "The app never halts below two seats, and the constitution proves one seat cannot halt.", evidence := (cons (record Production.ThreatModel::Evidence {kind := (ctor Production.ThreatModel::EvidenceKind.proof), reference := "CirisDeferralProofs::inv005Holds"}) (cons (record Production.ThreatModel::Evidence {kind := (ctor Production.ThreatModel::EvidenceKind.review), reference := "src/Constitution.lex.tex yubikeySingleSeatCannotHalt"}) (nil Production.ThreatModel::Evidence)))})
}

definition{
  name: modeledControlRegeneratedFromThePrompt,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ModeledControl,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ModeledControl {control := "Security::controlRegeneratedFromThePrompt", name := "Regenerated from the prompt", text := "The model is written from the prompt by the builder, and the build checks every theorem and replays every vector in the pinned SDK.", evidence := (cons (record Production.ThreatModel::Evidence {kind := (ctor Production.ThreatModel::EvidenceKind.gate), reference := "prismpm verify in the SDK image prismpm.lock pins"}) (cons (record Production.ThreatModel::Evidence {kind := (ctor Production.ThreatModel::EvidenceKind.review), reference := "app/prompt.json"}) (nil Production.ThreatModel::Evidence)))})
}

definition{
  name: modeledControlStrictDecoder,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ModeledControl,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ModeledControl {control := "Security::controlStrictDecoder", name := "Strict decoder", text := "Every field is decoded exactly: choices from their list, numbers as plain decimal digits within their bounds, single spaces between fields; anything else is invalid.", evidence := (cons (record Production.ThreatModel::Evidence {kind := (ctor Production.ThreatModel::EvidenceKind.gate), reference := "malformed-request acceptance vectors, replayed in the compiled guest by prismpm verify"}) (nil Production.ThreatModel::Evidence))})
}

definition{
  name: mappingOversizedRequest,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ThreatMapping,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ThreatMapping {threat := "Security::threatOversizedRequest", controls := (cons "Security::controlBoundedRequest" (nil String))})
}

definition{
  name: mappingSycophanticMonoculture,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ThreatMapping,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ThreatMapping {threat := "Security::threatSycophanticMonoculture", controls := (cons "Security::controlDiversityFloor" (nil String))})
}

definition{
  name: mappingSubstitutedHolo,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ThreatMapping,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ThreatMapping {threat := "Security::threatSubstitutedHolo", controls := (cons "Security::controlFingerprintAndProvenance" (nil String))})
}

definition{
  name: mappingGrantedCapability,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ThreatMapping,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ThreatMapping {threat := "Security::threatGrantedCapability", controls := (cons "Security::controlNoCapabilityGranted" (nil String))})
}

definition{
  name: mappingAnswerThatBreaksINV001,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ThreatMapping,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ThreatMapping {threat := "Security::threatAnswerThatBreaksINV001", controls := (cons "Security::controlProofOfINV001" (nil String))})
}

definition{
  name: mappingAnswerThatBreaksINV002,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ThreatMapping,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ThreatMapping {threat := "Security::threatAnswerThatBreaksINV002", controls := (cons "Security::controlProofOfINV002" (nil String))})
}

definition{
  name: mappingAnswerThatBreaksINV003,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ThreatMapping,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ThreatMapping {threat := "Security::threatAnswerThatBreaksINV003", controls := (cons "Security::controlProofOfINV003" (nil String))})
}

definition{
  name: mappingAnswerThatBreaksINV004,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ThreatMapping,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ThreatMapping {threat := "Security::threatAnswerThatBreaksINV004", controls := (cons "Security::controlProofOfINV004" (nil String))})
}

definition{
  name: mappingAnswerThatBreaksINV005,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ThreatMapping,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ThreatMapping {threat := "Security::threatAnswerThatBreaksINV005", controls := (cons "Security::controlProofOfINV005" (nil String))})
}

definition{
  name: mappingSingleSeatHalt,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ThreatMapping,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ThreatMapping {threat := "Security::threatSingleSeatHalt", controls := (cons "Security::controlQuorumProved" (nil String))})
}

definition{
  name: mappingTamperedModel,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ThreatMapping,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ThreatMapping {threat := "Security::threatTamperedModel", controls := (cons "Security::controlRegeneratedFromThePrompt" (nil String))})
}

definition{
  name: mappingMalformedRequest,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::ThreatMapping,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::ThreatMapping {threat := "Security::threatMalformedRequest", controls := (cons "Security::controlStrictDecoder" (nil String))})
}

definition{
  name: acceptedConscienceResultSpoofed,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::AcceptedRisk,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::AcceptedRisk {threat := "Security::threatConscienceResultSpoofed", rationale := "The app decides from the request it is given; the conscience result belongs to the H3ERE-06 stage that computes it, which the request names."})
}

definition{
  name: acceptedSubstitutedHost,
  parameters: [],
  result: Production.ThreatModel::AcceptedRisk,
  body: (record Production.ThreatModel::AcceptedRisk {threat := "Security::threatSubstitutedHost", rationale := "A page cannot defend against its own host. The holo carries signed build provenance a visitor can check, and the app can be rebuilt from its prompt."})
}
\end{semanticmodule}
\end{lexlean}
app/src/CirisDeferral.lex.tex 231 lines
\begin{lexlean}{CirisDeferral}
\useglossary{lexlean.std.bool@1.2.0}
\useglossary{lexlean.std.nat@1.2.0}
\useglossary{prism.arch@1.0.0}
\importmodule{Foundation.Bytes}
\importmodule{Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model}
\title{Text application model}
\begin{semanticmodule}
definition{name: consciencePassed, parameters: [], result: Nat, body: 0}

definition{name: conscienceVetoed, parameters: [], result: Nat, body: 1}

definition{name: answerProceed, parameters: [], result: Nat, body: 0}

definition{name: answerDefer, parameters: [], result: Nat, body: 1}

definition{name: answerHalt, parameters: [], result: Nat, body: 2}

structure{
  name: Request,
  type_parameters: [],
  parameters: [],
  fields: [
    {name: margin, type: Nat},
    {name: keff, type: Nat},
    {name: conscience, type: Nat},
    {name: seats, type: Nat}
  ]
}

definition{
  name: byteAt,
  parameters: [s : Bytes, i : Nat],
  result: (Option Nat),
  body: (match (prim index s i : (Option UInt8))
    | Option.none => (ctor Option.none [Nat])
    | Option.some b => (ctor Option.some [Nat] (prim to_nat b : Nat))),
  axioms: [Quot.sound, propext]
}

definition{
  name: digitsValue,
  parameters: [s : Bytes, i : Nat, acc : Nat, fuel : Nat],
  result: (Option Nat),
  body: (match fuel
    | Nat.zero => (ctor Option.some [Nat] acc)
    | Nat.succ rest => (match (byteAt s i)
      | Option.none => (ctor Option.none [Nat])
      | Option.some d => (if ((d <? 48) || (57 <? d)) then (ctor Option.none [Nat]) else (digitsValue s (i + 1) ((prim multiply acc 10 : Nat) + (prim subtract d 48 : Nat)) rest)))),
  axioms: [Quot.sound, propext],
  recursive_argument: fuel
}

definition{
  name: parseDigits,
  parameters: [s : Bytes],
  result: (Option Nat),
  body: (if ((Foundation.Bytes::byteLength s) =? 0) then (ctor Option.none [Nat]) else (if (18 <? (Foundation.Bytes::byteLength s)) then (ctor Option.none [Nat]) else (match (byteAt s 0)
    | Option.none => (ctor Option.none [Nat])
    | Option.some lead => (if ((lead =? 48) && (1 <? (Foundation.Bytes::byteLength s))) then (ctor Option.none [Nat]) else (digitsValue s 0 0 (Foundation.Bytes::byteLength s)))))),
  axioms: [Quot.sound, propext]
}

definition{
  name: parseNumber,
  parameters: [value : Bytes],
  result: (Option Nat),
  body: (parseDigits value),
  axioms: [Quot.sound, propext]
}

definition{
  name: parseMargin,
  parameters: [value : Bytes],
  result: (Option Nat),
  body: (match (parseNumber value)
    | Option.none => (ctor Option.none [Nat])
    | Option.some parsed => (if (100 <? parsed) then (ctor Option.none [Nat]) else (ctor Option.some [Nat] parsed))),
  axioms: [Quot.sound, propext]
}

definition{
  name: parseKeff,
  parameters: [value : Bytes],
  result: (Option Nat),
  body: (match (parseNumber value)
    | Option.none => (ctor Option.none [Nat])
    | Option.some parsed => (if (22 <? parsed) then (ctor Option.none [Nat]) else (ctor Option.some [Nat] parsed))),
  axioms: [Quot.sound, propext]
}

definition{
  name: parseConscience,
  parameters: [value : Bytes],
  result: (Option Nat),
  body: (if (prim equal value 0x706173736564 : Bool) then (ctor Option.some [Nat] (consciencePassed)) else (if (prim equal value 0x7665746f6564 : Bool) then (ctor Option.some [Nat] (conscienceVetoed)) else (ctor Option.none [Nat])))
}

definition{
  name: parseSeats,
  parameters: [value : Bytes],
  result: (Option Nat),
  body: (match (parseNumber value)
    | Option.none => (ctor Option.none [Nat])
    | Option.some parsed => (if (3 <? parsed) then (ctor Option.none [Nat]) else (ctor Option.some [Nat] parsed))),
  axioms: [Quot.sound, propext]
}

definition{
  name: sliceOf,
  parameters: [s : Bytes, start : Nat, count : Nat],
  result: Bytes,
  body: (match (prim slice s start count : (Option Bytes))
    | Option.none => 0x
    | Option.some part => part)
}

definition{
  name: fieldEnd,
  parameters: [s : Bytes, i : Nat, fuel : Nat],
  result: Nat,
  body: (match fuel
    | Nat.zero => i
    | Nat.succ rest => (match (byteAt s i)
      | Option.none => i
      | Option.some d => (if (d =? 32) then i else (fieldEnd s (i + 1) rest)))),
  axioms: [Quot.sound, propext],
  recursive_argument: fuel
}

definition{
  name: decodeField4,
  parameters: [s : Bytes, start : Nat, v1 : Nat, v2 : Nat, v3 : Nat],
  result: (Option Request),
  body: (let e : Nat := (fieldEnd s start (Foundation.Bytes::byteLength s)); (match (parseSeats (sliceOf s start (prim subtract e start : Nat)))
    | Option.none => (ctor Option.none [Request])
    | Option.some v4 => (if (e =? (Foundation.Bytes::byteLength s)) then (ctor Option.some [Request] (record Request {margin := v1, keff := v2, conscience := v3, seats := v4})) else (ctor Option.none [Request])))),
  axioms: [Quot.sound, propext]
}

definition{
  name: decodeField3,
  parameters: [s : Bytes, start : Nat, v1 : Nat, v2 : Nat],
  result: (Option Request),
  body: (let e : Nat := (fieldEnd s start (Foundation.Bytes::byteLength s)); (match (parseConscience (sliceOf s start (prim subtract e start : Nat)))
    | Option.none => (ctor Option.none [Request])
    | Option.some v3 => (if (e <? (Foundation.Bytes::byteLength s)) then (decodeField4 s (e + 1) v1 v2 v3) else (ctor Option.none [Request])))),
  axioms: [Quot.sound, propext]
}

definition{
  name: decodeField2,
  parameters: [s : Bytes, start : Nat, v1 : Nat],
  result: (Option Request),
  body: (let e : Nat := (fieldEnd s start (Foundation.Bytes::byteLength s)); (match (parseKeff (sliceOf s start (prim subtract e start : Nat)))
    | Option.none => (ctor Option.none [Request])
    | Option.some v2 => (if (e <? (Foundation.Bytes::byteLength s)) then (decodeField3 s (e + 1) v1 v2) else (ctor Option.none [Request])))),
  axioms: [Quot.sound, propext]
}

definition{
  name: decodeField1,
  parameters: [s : Bytes, start : Nat],
  result: (Option Request),
  body: (let e : Nat := (fieldEnd s start (Foundation.Bytes::byteLength s)); (match (parseMargin (sliceOf s start (prim subtract e start : Nat)))
    | Option.none => (ctor Option.none [Request])
    | Option.some v1 => (if (e <? (Foundation.Bytes::byteLength s)) then (decodeField2 s (e + 1) v1) else (ctor Option.none [Request])))),
  axioms: [Quot.sound, propext]
}

definition{
  name: rule1,
  parameters: [request : Request],
  result: Bool,
  body: (2 <=? (project request seats))
}

definition{
  name: rule2,
  parameters: [request : Request],
  result: Bool,
  body: ((project request conscience) =? (conscienceVetoed))
}

definition{
  name: rule3,
  parameters: [request : Request],
  result: Bool,
  body: ((project request keff) <? 4)
}

definition{
  name: rule4,
  parameters: [request : Request],
  result: Bool,
  body: ((project request margin) <? 15)
}

definition{
  name: judge,
  parameters: [request : Request],
  result: Nat,
  body: (if (rule1 request) then (answerHalt) else (if (rule2 request) then (answerDefer) else (if (rule3 request) then (answerDefer) else (if (rule4 request) then (answerDefer) else (answerProceed)))))
}

definition{
  name: encodeAnswer,
  parameters: [code : Nat],
  result: Bytes,
  body: (if (code =? (answerProceed)) then 0x70726f63656564 else (if (code =? (answerDefer)) then 0x6465666572 else (if (code =? (answerHalt)) then 0x68616c74 else 0x696e76616c6964)))
}

definition{
  name: dispatch,
  parameters: [value : Bytes],
  result: Bytes,
  body: (if (112 <? (Foundation.Bytes::byteLength value)) then 0x696e76616c6964 else (match (decodeField1 value 0)
    | Option.none => 0x696e76616c6964
    | Option.some request => (encodeAnswer (judge request)))),
  axioms: [Quot.sound, propext]
}

definition{
  name: application,
  parameters: [],
  result: Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::TextApplication,
  body: (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::TextApplication {profile := "prismpm/text-application/1", name := "Wise deferral", cargoName := "prism-ciris-deferral", cargoVersion := "0.1.0", cargoDescription := "Decide whether an agent proceeds, defers to a wise authority, or is halted, from its confidence margin, the diversity of its perspectives, the conscience gate and the Wise Authority seats that signed ", cargoRepository := "https://github.com/UOR-Foundation/PrismPM", cargoHomepage := "https://github.com/UOR-Foundation/PrismPM", libraryRoots := (cons "PrismCirisDeferral.CirisDeferral.dispatch" (nil String)), acceptanceVectors := (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x33352036207061737365642030, response := 0x70726f63656564}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x382035207061737365642030, response := 0x6465666572}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x33352032207061737365642030, response := 0x6465666572}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x37352038207665746f65642030, response := 0x6465666572}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x33352036207061737365642032, response := 0x68616c74}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x33352036207061737365642031, response := 0x70726f63656564}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x302030207061737365642030, response := 0x6465666572}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x302030207061737365642032, response := 0x68616c74}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x302030207665746f65642030, response := 0x6465666572}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x302030207665746f65642032, response := 0x68616c74}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x302034207061737365642030, response := 0x6465666572}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x302034207061737365642032, response := 0x68616c74}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x302034207665746f65642030, response := 0x6465666572}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x302034207665746f65642032, response := 0x68616c74}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x31352030207061737365642030, response := 0x6465666572}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x31352030207061737365642032, response := 0x68616c74}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x31352030207665746f65642030, response := 0x6465666572}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x31352030207665746f65642032, response := 0x68616c74}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x31352034207061737365642030, response := 0x70726f63656564}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x31352034207061737365642032, response := 0x68616c74}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x31352034207665746f65642030, response := 0x6465666572}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x31352034207665746f65642032, response := 0x68616c74}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x, response := 0x696e76616c6964}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0xff, response := 0x696e76616c6964}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x30203020706173736564, response := 0x696e76616c6964}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x3020302070617373656420302030, response := 0x696e76616c6964}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x302020302020706173736564202030, response := 0x696e76616c6964}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x30372030207061737365642030, response := 0x696e76616c6964}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x2d312030207061737365642030, response := 0x696e76616c6964}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x2b312030207061737365642030, response := 0x696e76616c6964}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x313030303030303030303030303030303030302030207061737365642030, response := 0x696e76616c6964}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0xd9a12030207061737365642030, response := 0x696e76616c6964}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x782030207061737365642030, response := 0x696e76616c6964}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x3130312030207061737365642030, response := 0x696e76616c6964}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x30203037207061737365642030, response := 0x696e76616c6964}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x30202d31207061737365642030, response := 0x696e76616c6964}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x30202b31207061737365642030, response := 0x696e76616c6964}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x302031303030303030303030303030303030303030207061737365642030, response := 0x696e76616c6964}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x3020d9a1207061737365642030, response := 0x696e76616c6964}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x302078207061737365642030, response := 0x696e76616c6964}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x30203233207061737365642030, response := 0x696e76616c6964}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x30203020756e6b6e6f776e2030, response := 0x696e76616c6964}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x30203020706173736564203037, response := 0x696e76616c6964}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x30203020706173736564202d31, response := 0x696e76616c6964}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x30203020706173736564202b31, response := 0x696e76616c6964}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x302030207061737365642031303030303030303030303030303030303030, response := 0x696e76616c6964}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x3020302070617373656420d9a1, response := 0x696e76616c6964}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x302030207061737365642078, response := 0x696e76616c6964}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x302030207061737365642034, response := 0x696e76616c6964}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x78787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878, response := 0x696e76616c6964}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x7878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878, response := 0x696e76616c6964}) (cons (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector {request := 0x7878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878787878, response := 0x696e76616c6964}) (nil Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::AcceptanceVector))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))), entryRoot := "PrismCirisDeferral.CirisDeferral.dispatch", coreContract := "hologram:guest/core-wasm@1", requestMaximum := (112 : UInt32), responseMaximum := (64 : UInt32), guestAllocationMaximum := (224 : UInt32), capabilitiesEmpty := true, fatArchive := true, primaryLayer := (0 : UInt8), viewLayer := (1 : UInt8), view := (record Foundation.View.Text.V1.Model::TextView {title := "Wise deferral", heading := "Wise deferral", inputLabel := "Request: margin keff conscience seats", submitLabel := "Decide", outputLabel := "Answer", inputError := "Invalid request", responseError := "Invalid response"})})
}
\end{semanticmodule}
\end{lexlean}
app/src/CirisDeferralProofs.lex.tex 154 lines
\begin{lexlean}{CirisDeferralProofs}
\useglossary{lexlean.std.bool@1.2.0}
\useglossary{lexlean.std.nat@1.2.0}
\useglossary{prism.arch@1.0.0}
\importmodule{CirisDeferral}
\title{Text application model}
\begin{semanticmodule}
definition{
  name: breaksInv001,
  parameters: [request : CirisDeferral::Request],
  result: Bool,
  body: (((((((project request margin) <=? 100) && ((project request keff) <=? 22)) && ((project request conscience) <? 2)) && ((project request seats) <=? 3)) && ((project request conscience) =? (CirisDeferral::conscienceVetoed))) && ((CirisDeferral::judge request) =? (CirisDeferral::answerProceed)))
}

theorem{
  name: inv001Holds,
  parameters: [request : CirisDeferral::Request],
  statement: ((breaksInv001 request) = false),
  proof: linear_arithmetic{
    definitions: [
      CirisDeferral::answerDefer,
      CirisDeferral::answerHalt,
      CirisDeferral::answerProceed,
      CirisDeferral::consciencePassed,
      CirisDeferral::conscienceVetoed,
      CirisDeferral::judge,
      CirisDeferral::rule1,
      CirisDeferral::rule2,
      CirisDeferral::rule3,
      CirisDeferral::rule4,
      breaksInv001
    ]
  },
  axioms: [Quot.sound, propext]
}

definition{
  name: breaksInv002,
  parameters: [request : CirisDeferral::Request],
  result: Bool,
  body: (((((((project request margin) <=? 100) && ((project request keff) <=? 22)) && ((project request conscience) <? 2)) && ((project request seats) <=? 3)) && ((project request keff) <? 4)) && ((CirisDeferral::judge request) =? (CirisDeferral::answerProceed)))
}

theorem{
  name: inv002Holds,
  parameters: [request : CirisDeferral::Request],
  statement: ((breaksInv002 request) = false),
  proof: linear_arithmetic{
    definitions: [
      CirisDeferral::answerDefer,
      CirisDeferral::answerHalt,
      CirisDeferral::answerProceed,
      CirisDeferral::consciencePassed,
      CirisDeferral::conscienceVetoed,
      CirisDeferral::judge,
      CirisDeferral::rule1,
      CirisDeferral::rule2,
      CirisDeferral::rule3,
      CirisDeferral::rule4,
      breaksInv002
    ]
  },
  axioms: [Quot.sound, propext]
}

definition{
  name: breaksInv003,
  parameters: [request : CirisDeferral::Request],
  result: Bool,
  body: (((((((project request margin) <=? 100) && ((project request keff) <=? 22)) && ((project request conscience) <? 2)) && ((project request seats) <=? 3)) && ((project request margin) <? 15)) && ((CirisDeferral::judge request) =? (CirisDeferral::answerProceed)))
}

theorem{
  name: inv003Holds,
  parameters: [request : CirisDeferral::Request],
  statement: ((breaksInv003 request) = false),
  proof: linear_arithmetic{
    definitions: [
      CirisDeferral::answerDefer,
      CirisDeferral::answerHalt,
      CirisDeferral::answerProceed,
      CirisDeferral::consciencePassed,
      CirisDeferral::conscienceVetoed,
      CirisDeferral::judge,
      CirisDeferral::rule1,
      CirisDeferral::rule2,
      CirisDeferral::rule3,
      CirisDeferral::rule4,
      breaksInv003
    ]
  },
  axioms: [Quot.sound, propext]
}

definition{
  name: breaksInv004,
  parameters: [request : CirisDeferral::Request],
  result: Bool,
  body: (((((((project request margin) <=? 100) && ((project request keff) <=? 22)) && ((project request conscience) <? 2)) && ((project request seats) <=? 3)) && (2 <=? (project request seats))) && (not ((CirisDeferral::judge request) =? (CirisDeferral::answerHalt))))
}

theorem{
  name: inv004Holds,
  parameters: [request : CirisDeferral::Request],
  statement: ((breaksInv004 request) = false),
  proof: linear_arithmetic{
    definitions: [
      CirisDeferral::answerDefer,
      CirisDeferral::answerHalt,
      CirisDeferral::answerProceed,
      CirisDeferral::consciencePassed,
      CirisDeferral::conscienceVetoed,
      CirisDeferral::judge,
      CirisDeferral::rule1,
      CirisDeferral::rule2,
      CirisDeferral::rule3,
      CirisDeferral::rule4,
      breaksInv004
    ]
  },
  axioms: [Quot.sound, propext]
}

definition{
  name: breaksInv005,
  parameters: [request : CirisDeferral::Request],
  result: Bool,
  body: (((((((project request margin) <=? 100) && ((project request keff) <=? 22)) && ((project request conscience) <? 2)) && ((project request seats) <=? 3)) && ((project request seats) <? 2)) && ((CirisDeferral::judge request) =? (CirisDeferral::answerHalt)))
}

theorem{
  name: inv005Holds,
  parameters: [request : CirisDeferral::Request],
  statement: ((breaksInv005 request) = false),
  proof: linear_arithmetic{
    definitions: [
      CirisDeferral::answerDefer,
      CirisDeferral::answerHalt,
      CirisDeferral::answerProceed,
      CirisDeferral::consciencePassed,
      CirisDeferral::conscienceVetoed,
      CirisDeferral::judge,
      CirisDeferral::rule1,
      CirisDeferral::rule2,
      CirisDeferral::rule3,
      CirisDeferral::rule4,
      breaksInv005
    ]
  },
  axioms: [Quot.sound, propext]
}
\end{semanticmodule}
\end{lexlean}
app/lexlean.toml 43 lines
spec = "lexlean/project/1"
name = "prism-ciris-deferral"
language = "1.2"
module_prefix = "PrismCirisDeferral"
source_roots = ["src"]
entrypoints = ["src/Architecture.lex.tex", "src/CirisDeferral.lex.tex", "src/CirisDeferralProofs.lex.tex", "src/Compliance.lex.tex", "src/Design.lex.tex", "src/Features.lex.tex", "src/Quality.lex.tex", "src/Security.lex.tex"]
build_root = ".lexlean"
lockfile = "lexlean.lock"
lean_workspace = "."
lean_toolchain = "leanprover/lean4:v4.32.1"

[[lexicon_source]]
package = "lexlean.std.nat"
kind = "builtin"

[[lexicon_source]]
package = "prism.arch"
kind = "path"
path = "language/prism.arch"

[[lexicon_source]]
package = "prism.qual"
kind = "path"
path = "language/prism.qual"

[[lexicon_source]]
package = "prism.sec"
kind = "path"
path = "language/prism.sec"

[limits]
max_file_bytes = 4194304
max_total_source_bytes = 67108864
max_primitive_atoms = 2000000
max_token_lattice_edges = 4000000
max_parse_states = 4000000
max_ir_nodes = 2000000
max_scope_depth = 1024
max_import_depth = 128
max_diagnostics = 256
max_child_output_bytes = 16777216
child_timeout_ms = 300000
app/prompt.json 328 lines
{
  "schema": "prism/prompt/1",
  "goal": "Decide if a CIRIS agent goes ahead, asks a Wise Authority first, or stops. Then each of its choices can be checked later.",
  "pattern": "decisionTable",
  "repository": "afflom/prism-ciris",
  "app": {
    "name": "ciris-deferral",
    "title": "Wise deferral",
    "purpose": "Decide whether an agent proceeds, defers to a wise authority, or is halted, from its confidence margin, the diversity of its perspectives, the conscience gate and the Wise Authority seats that signed a halt.",
    "fields": [
      {
        "name": "margin",
        "kind": "number",
        "min": 0,
        "means": "the top score minus the runner-up score",
        "max": 100
      },
      {
        "name": "keff",
        "kind": "number",
        "min": 0,
        "means": "the Kish effective number of independent perspectives",
        "max": 22
      },
      {
        "name": "conscience",
        "kind": "choice",
        "values": [
          "passed",
          "vetoed"
        ],
        "means": "what the H3ERE-06 conscience gate said"
      },
      {
        "name": "seats",
        "kind": "number",
        "min": 0,
        "means": "Wise Authority Yubikey seats that signed a halt",
        "max": 3
      }
    ],
    "outcomes": [
      "proceed",
      "defer",
      "halt"
    ],
    "meanings": {
      "proceed": "the agent acts autonomously",
      "defer": "a Wise Authority decides, wisdom-based deferral",
      "halt": "the agent stops, by a 2-of-3 Yubikey quorum"
    },
    "rules": [
      {
        "when": [
          {
            "field": "seats",
            "op": ">=",
            "value": 2
          }
        ],
        "then": "halt",
        "why": "src/Constitution.lex.tex checkYubikeyHaltQuorum: two of the three seats halt the agent (yubikeyTwoOfThreeQuorumHalts)"
      },
      {
        "when": [
          {
            "field": "conscience",
            "op": "is",
            "value": "vetoed"
          }
        ],
        "then": "defer",
        "why": "src/H3ERE.lex.tex decideOrDeferToWa: a failed conscience gate defers (conscienceVetoForcesDeferralOrHalt)"
      },
      {
        "when": [
          {
            "field": "keff",
            "op": "<",
            "value": 4
          }
        ],
        "then": "defer",
        "why": "src/H3ERE.lex.tex: k_eff below minimumEpistemicDiversityKeff, 4, defers (lowDiversityTriggersWisdomBasedDeferral)"
      },
      {
        "when": [
          {
            "field": "margin",
            "op": "<",
            "value": 15
          }
        ],
        "then": "defer",
        "why": "src/H3ERE.lex.tex: a margin below minimumConfidenceMargin, 15, defers (lowMarginTriggersWisdomBasedDeferral)"
      }
    ],
    "otherwise": "proceed",
    "otherwiseWhy": "src/H3ERE.lex.tex highMarginAndDiversityPermitsAutonomousAction: conscience passed, diverse and confident",
    "properties": [
      {
        "kind": "never",
        "when": [
          {
            "field": "conscience",
            "op": "is",
            "value": "vetoed"
          }
        ],
        "then": "proceed",
        "why": "the conscience gate is a non-bypassable final veto"
      },
      {
        "kind": "never",
        "when": [
          {
            "field": "keff",
            "op": "<",
            "value": 4
          }
        ],
        "then": "proceed",
        "why": "a monoculture of perspectives never acts alone"
      },
      {
        "kind": "never",
        "when": [
          {
            "field": "margin",
            "op": "<",
            "value": 15
          }
        ],
        "then": "proceed",
        "why": "the agent does not act on a near tie"
      },
      {
        "kind": "always",
        "when": [
          {
            "field": "seats",
            "op": ">=",
            "value": 2
          }
        ],
        "then": "halt",
        "why": "a 2-of-3 Yubikey quorum always halts"
      },
      {
        "kind": "never",
        "when": [
          {
            "field": "seats",
            "op": "<",
            "value": 2
          }
        ],
        "then": "halt",
        "why": "yubikeySingleSeatCannotHalt: one seat alone cannot halt"
      }
    ],
    "examples": [
      {
        "request": "35 6 passed 0",
        "response": "proceed"
      },
      {
        "request": "8 5 passed 0",
        "response": "defer"
      },
      {
        "request": "35 2 passed 0",
        "response": "defer"
      },
      {
        "request": "75 8 vetoed 0",
        "response": "defer"
      },
      {
        "request": "35 6 passed 2",
        "response": "halt"
      },
      {
        "request": "35 6 passed 1",
        "response": "proceed"
      }
    ]
  },
  "stakeholders": [
    {
      "name": "Agent operator",
      "text": "Runs an agent and needs every action it takes to be one the covenant allows.",
      "concerns": [
        "Correct answers",
        "Proved guarantees"
      ]
    },
    {
      "name": "Affected person",
      "text": "Is affected by what the agent does and needs an uncertain or vetoed action to reach a person first.",
      "concerns": [
        "Proved guarantees"
      ]
    },
    {
      "name": "Wise Authority",
      "text": "Holds a Yubikey seat and needs a 2-of-3 quorum to halt the agent, and one seat never to.",
      "concerns": [
        "Halt by quorum"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "concerns": [
    {
      "name": "Halt by quorum",
      "text": "Two of the three Wise Authority seats halt the agent, and a single seat cannot, as Constitution.lex.tex checks.",
      "model": "security"
    }
  ],
  "components": [
    {
      "name": "H3ERE pipeline",
      "text": "The 6-stage CSDMA, DSDMA, PDMA, IDMA, ASPDMA and conscience pipeline that computes the margin, k_eff and conscience result.",
      "kind": "service"
    },
    {
      "name": "Wise Authority",
      "text": "The human Wise Authority, ciris.wa.*, that receives deferrals and holds the Yubikey halt seats.",
      "kind": "externalSystem"
    }
  ],
  "threats": [
    {
      "name": "Conscience result spoofed",
      "text": "A caller reports that the conscience gate passed when it vetoed, to make the agent act.",
      "stride": "spoofing",
      "asset": "request",
      "likelihood": "medium",
      "impact": "major",
      "accepted": "The app decides from the request it is given; the conscience result belongs to the H3ERE-06 stage that computes it, which the request names."
    },
    {
      "name": "Single-seat halt",
      "text": "One Wise Authority seat halts the agent alone, or impersonates a quorum.",
      "stride": "elevationOfPrivilege",
      "asset": "answer",
      "likelihood": "low",
      "impact": "major",
      "control": {
        "name": "Quorum proved",
        "text": "The app never halts below two seats, and the constitution proves one seat cannot halt.",
        "evidence": [
          {
            "kind": "proof",
            "reference": "CirisDeferralProofs::inv005Holds"
          },
          {
            "kind": "review",
            "reference": "src/Constitution.lex.tex yubikeySingleSeatCannotHalt"
          }
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "name": "Sycophantic monoculture",
      "text": "The agent acts when its perspectives are not independent, so one view decides.",
      "stride": "tampering",
      "asset": "answer",
      "likelihood": "medium",
      "impact": "critical",
      "control": {
        "name": "Diversity floor",
        "text": "Below k_eff 4 the agent defers, proved for every request.",
        "evidence": [
          {
            "kind": "proof",
            "reference": "CirisDeferralProofs::inv002Holds"
          },
          {
            "kind": "review",
            "reference": "src/Coherence.lex.tex Kish k_eff verifier"
          }
        ]
      }
    }
  ],
  "quality": [
    {
      "characteristic": "Safety",
      "subcharacteristic": "Fail safe",
      "requirement": "Uncertainty defers",
      "text": "Every request with a vetoed conscience, k_eff below 4 or a margin below 15 is answered defer or halt.",
      "measure": "Autonomous answers under uncertainty",
      "measureText": "Requests with a veto, low diversity or low margin that are answered proceed.",
      "threshold": 0
    }
  ],
  "journeys": [
    {
      "stakeholder": "Agent operator",
      "steps": [
        "REQ-002",
        "REQ-003",
        "REQ-004",
        "otherwise"
      ]
    },
    {
      "stakeholder": "Affected person",
      "steps": [
        "INV-001",
        "INV-002",
        "INV-003"
      ]
    },
    {
      "stakeholder": "Wise Authority",
      "steps": [
        "REQ-001",
        "INV-004",
        "INV-005"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "license": "MIT OR Apache-2.0",
  "axioms": {}
}
model/ids.toml 71 lines
# model/ids.toml --- the conformance ID register.
#
# Every ID this repository claims, in one place, so that nothing is referenced
# without being defined. `CONFORMANCE.md` is generated from this file. A test
# whose name ends in an ID not listed here fails `check-model`, and an ID listed
# here with no scenario and no test fails it too (CM-02).
#
# `level` is the honesty level (R2):
#   some-true  a fact reproduced from an authority; not established here
#   build      constructed here and validated against its oracle
#   open       measured and reported, never asserted
#
# Every row here has a scenario in `features/suites/` and a test whose name ends
# in the ID, lowercased with underscores (R3, CM-02). There is no "pending"
# state: a capability that is not built does not get a row, and every row in this
# file is built.
#
# The first row is the template's own Prism application in `app/` (TC-01).
# A capability starts with a row here; `just new-capability` writes the row,
# its scenario and its failing test in the order `AGENTS.md` sets out.

spec = "template/1"

[[id]]
id = "CD-01"
level = "build"
suite = "ciris_deferral"
statement = "The app never answers proceed when conscience is vetoed"

[[id]]
id = "CD-02"
level = "build"
suite = "ciris_deferral"
statement = "The app never answers proceed when keff is below 4"

[[id]]
id = "CD-03"
level = "build"
suite = "ciris_deferral"
statement = "The app never answers proceed when margin is below 15"

[[id]]
id = "CD-04"
level = "build"
suite = "ciris_deferral"
statement = "The app always answers halt when seats is at least 2"

[[id]]
id = "CD-05"
level = "build"
suite = "ciris_deferral"
statement = "The app never answers halt when seats is below 2"

[[id]]
id = "CD-06"
level = "build"
suite = "ciris_deferral"
statement = "The architecture description declares every stakeholder, concern, component, edge, viewpoint and view it references"

[[id]]
id = "CD-07"
level = "build"
suite = "ciris_deferral"
statement = "The ISO/IEC 25010 quality model numbers every characteristic, subcharacteristic, requirement and measure, and every parent it names is declared"

[[id]]
id = "CD-08"
level = "build"
suite = "ciris_deferral"
statement = "Every compliance obligation is numbered in order and names its evidence"
features/suites/ciris_deferral.feature 50 lines
Feature: ciris_deferral

  This repository's Prism application, in app/, generated by prism-code from its
  spec: Decide whether an agent proceeds, defers to a wise authority, or is halted, from its confidence margin, the diversity of its perspectives, the conscience gate and the Wise Authority seats that signed a halt.

  @CD-01 @build
  Scenario: The app never answers proceed when conscience is vetoed
    Given the model in app/src/CirisDeferral.lex.tex
    When the Lean kernel checks inv001Holds during prismpm verify
    Then no request meets breaksInv001

  @CD-02 @build
  Scenario: The app never answers proceed when keff is below 4
    Given the model in app/src/CirisDeferral.lex.tex
    When the Lean kernel checks inv002Holds during prismpm verify
    Then no request meets breaksInv002

  @CD-03 @build
  Scenario: The app never answers proceed when margin is below 15
    Given the model in app/src/CirisDeferral.lex.tex
    When the Lean kernel checks inv003Holds during prismpm verify
    Then no request meets breaksInv003

  @CD-04 @build
  Scenario: The app always answers halt when seats is at least 2
    Given the model in app/src/CirisDeferral.lex.tex
    When the Lean kernel checks inv004Holds during prismpm verify
    Then no request meets breaksInv004

  @CD-05 @build
  Scenario: The app never answers halt when seats is below 2
    Given the model in app/src/CirisDeferral.lex.tex
    When the Lean kernel checks inv005Holds during prismpm verify
    Then no request meets breaksInv005
  @CD-06 @build
  Scenario: The architecture description declares every stakeholder, concern, component, edge, viewpoint and view it references
    Given the model in app/src/Architecture.lex.tex
    When the Lean kernel checks architectureDescriptionHolds during prismpm verify
    Then the architecture description declares every stakeholder, concern, component, edge, viewpoint and view it references
  @CD-07 @build
  Scenario: The ISO/IEC 25010 quality model numbers every characteristic, subcharacteristic, requirement and measure, and every parent it names is declared
    Given the model in app/src/Quality.lex.tex
    When the Lean kernel checks qualityModelHolds during prismpm verify
    Then the ISO/IEC 25010 quality model numbers every characteristic, subcharacteristic, requirement and measure, and every parent it names is declared
  @CD-08 @build
  Scenario: Every compliance obligation is numbered in order and names its evidence
    Given the model in app/src/Compliance.lex.tex
    When the Lean kernel checks everyObligationEvidenced during prismpm verify
    Then every compliance obligation is numbered in order and names its evidence
crates/conformance/tests/ciris_deferral.rs 142 lines
//! The `ciris_deferral` suite: one test per scenario in `features/suites/ciris_deferral.feature`.
//!
//! Written by the Prism-DevRel builder from the app's prompt. The theorems are
//! checked by the Lean kernel when `just vv` runs `prismpm verify` on `app/`.
//! What these tests hold fixed is what each theorem is about, so a weakened
//! statement that still verifies fails the gate.

use std::path::PathBuf;

fn root() -> PathBuf {
    PathBuf::from(env!("CARGO_MANIFEST_DIR"))
        .ancestors()
        .nth(2)
        .expect("crates/conformance is two below the root")
        .to_path_buf()
}

/// The body of the top-level declaration named `name`, up to its closing brace.
fn declaration<'a>(model: &'a str, name: &str) -> &'a str {
    let start = model
        .find(&format!("\n  name: {name},\n"))
        .unwrap_or_else(|| panic!("{name} is not declared"));
    let end = model[start..]
        .find("\n}\n")
        .unwrap_or_else(|| panic!("{name} is not closed"));
    &model[start..start + end]
}

fn module(path: &str) -> String {
    std::fs::read_to_string(root().join(path)).expect("the module")
}

/// The condition no request may meet, and the theorem that says none does.
fn pinned(breaks: &str, condition: &str, theorem: &str) {
    let model = module("app/src/CirisDeferralProofs.lex.tex");
    let found = declaration(&model, breaks);
    assert!(
        found.contains(condition),
        "the condition of {breaks} changed:\n{found}"
    );
    let holds = declaration(&model, theorem);
    let statement = format!("statement: (({breaks} request) = false),");
    assert!(
        holds.contains(&statement),
        "{theorem} must state that no request meets {breaks}:\n{holds}"
    );
}

/// A facet theorem: proved by `decide`, about exactly this predicate.
fn holds(path: &str, theorem: &str, statement: &str) {
    let model = module(path);
    let found = declaration(&model, theorem);
    assert!(
        found.contains(&format!("statement: {statement},")),
        "{theorem} must state {statement}:\n{found}"
    );
    assert!(
        found.contains("proof: decide{}"),
        "{theorem} is proved by decide"
    );
}

/// `CD-01`: The app never answers proceed when conscience is vetoed
#[test]
fn ciris_deferral_cd_01() {
    pinned(
        "breaksInv001",
        "body: (((((((project request margin) <=? 100) && ((project request keff) <=? 22)) && ((project request conscience) <? 2)) && ((project request seats) <=? 3)) && ((project request conscience) =? (CirisDeferral::conscienceVetoed))) && ((CirisDeferral::judge request) =? (CirisDeferral::answerProceed)))",
        "inv001Holds",
    );
}

/// `CD-02`: The app never answers proceed when keff is below 4
#[test]
fn ciris_deferral_cd_02() {
    pinned(
        "breaksInv002",
        "body: (((((((project request margin) <=? 100) && ((project request keff) <=? 22)) && ((project request conscience) <? 2)) && ((project request seats) <=? 3)) && ((project request keff) <? 4)) && ((CirisDeferral::judge request) =? (CirisDeferral::answerProceed)))",
        "inv002Holds",
    );
}

/// `CD-03`: The app never answers proceed when margin is below 15
#[test]
fn ciris_deferral_cd_03() {
    pinned(
        "breaksInv003",
        "body: (((((((project request margin) <=? 100) && ((project request keff) <=? 22)) && ((project request conscience) <? 2)) && ((project request seats) <=? 3)) && ((project request margin) <? 15)) && ((CirisDeferral::judge request) =? (CirisDeferral::answerProceed)))",
        "inv003Holds",
    );
}

/// `CD-04`: The app always answers halt when seats is at least 2
#[test]
fn ciris_deferral_cd_04() {
    pinned(
        "breaksInv004",
        "body: (((((((project request margin) <=? 100) && ((project request keff) <=? 22)) && ((project request conscience) <? 2)) && ((project request seats) <=? 3)) && (2 <=? (project request seats))) && (not ((CirisDeferral::judge request) =? (CirisDeferral::answerHalt))))",
        "inv004Holds",
    );
}

/// `CD-05`: The app never answers halt when seats is below 2
#[test]
fn ciris_deferral_cd_05() {
    pinned(
        "breaksInv005",
        "body: (((((((project request margin) <=? 100) && ((project request keff) <=? 22)) && ((project request conscience) <? 2)) && ((project request seats) <=? 3)) && ((project request seats) <? 2)) && ((CirisDeferral::judge request) =? (CirisDeferral::answerHalt)))",
        "inv005Holds",
    );
}

/// `CD-06`: The architecture description declares every stakeholder, concern, component, edge, viewpoint and view it references
#[test]
fn ciris_deferral_cd_06() {
    holds(
        "app/src/Architecture.lex.tex",
        "architectureDescriptionHolds",
        "((architectureValid) = true)",
    );
}

/// `CD-07`: The ISO/IEC 25010 quality model numbers every characteristic, subcharacteristic, requirement and measure, and every parent it names is declared
#[test]
fn ciris_deferral_cd_07() {
    holds(
        "app/src/Quality.lex.tex",
        "qualityModelHolds",
        "((qualityValid) = true)",
    );
}

/// `CD-08`: Every compliance obligation is numbered in order and names its evidence
#[test]
fn ciris_deferral_cd_08() {
    holds(
        "app/src/Compliance.lex.tex",
        "everyObligationEvidenced",
        "((obligationsEvidenced 0 (obligations)) = true)",
    );
}
site/app.json 124 lines
{
  "name": "Wise deferral",
  "shortName": "Wise",
  "live": "https://afflom.github.io/prism-ciris/",
  "purpose": "Decide whether an agent proceeds, defers to a wise authority, or is halted, from its confidence margin, the diversity of its perspectives, the conscience gate and the Wise Authority seats that signed a halt. Send margin, keff, conscience or seats, separated by spaces; it answers proceed, defer or halt, and invalid request for anything else.",
  "inputLabel": "Request: margin keff conscience seats",
  "placeholder": "35 6 passed 0",
  "submitLabel": "Decide",
  "outputLabel": "Answer",
  "answers": {
    "positive": [
      "proceed"
    ],
    "negative": [
      "defer",
      "halt"
    ],
    "refusal": "invalid request"
  },
  "promise": {
    "headline": "Says conformant exactly when every policy file matches its lock.",
    "detail": "Each of the six universal policy files is compared with the digest the lock records, and any file that drifted is named."
  },
  "claim": "CD-01: the app never answers proceed when conscience is vetoed. CD-02: the app never answers proceed when keff is below 4. CD-03: the app never answers proceed when margin is below 15. CD-04: the app always answers halt when seats is at least 2. CD-05: the app never answers halt when seats is below 2.",
  "proposition": {
    "name": "judge",
    "text": "judge request :=\n  seats is at least 2 → halt\n  conscience is vetoed → defer\n  keff is below 4 → defer\n  margin is below 15 → defer\n  otherwise → proceed",
    "plain": "Decide whether an agent proceeds, defers to a wise authority, or is halted, from its confidence margin, the diversity of its perspectives, the conscience gate and the Wise Authority seats that signed a halt."
  },
  "theorems": [
    {
      "name": "inv001Holds",
      "statement": "no request meets breaksInv001: the app never answers proceed when conscience is vetoed",
      "how": "Proved by linear arithmetic, checked by the Lean kernel on the UOR MCP server and again by prismpm verify in CI",
      "where": "app/src/CirisDeferralProofs.lex.tex"
    },
    {
      "name": "inv002Holds",
      "statement": "no request meets breaksInv002: the app never answers proceed when keff is below 4",
      "how": "Proved by linear arithmetic, checked by the Lean kernel on the UOR MCP server and again by prismpm verify in CI",
      "where": "app/src/CirisDeferralProofs.lex.tex"
    },
    {
      "name": "inv003Holds",
      "statement": "no request meets breaksInv003: the app never answers proceed when margin is below 15",
      "how": "Proved by linear arithmetic, checked by the Lean kernel on the UOR MCP server and again by prismpm verify in CI",
      "where": "app/src/CirisDeferralProofs.lex.tex"
    },
    {
      "name": "inv004Holds",
      "statement": "no request meets breaksInv004: the app always answers halt when seats is at least 2",
      "how": "Proved by linear arithmetic, checked by the Lean kernel on the UOR MCP server and again by prismpm verify in CI",
      "where": "app/src/CirisDeferralProofs.lex.tex"
    },
    {
      "name": "inv005Holds",
      "statement": "no request meets breaksInv005: the app never answers halt when seats is below 2",
      "how": "Proved by linear arithmetic, checked by the Lean kernel on the UOR MCP server and again by prismpm verify in CI",
      "where": "app/src/CirisDeferralProofs.lex.tex"
    }
  ],
  "pinned": [
    {
      "name": "ciris_deferral_cd_01",
      "what": "CD-01's condition and the theorem that no request meets it. A string-matching test, not a theorem: a planted defect fails it.",
      "where": "crates/conformance/tests/ciris_deferral.rs"
    },
    {
      "name": "ciris_deferral_cd_02",
      "what": "CD-02's condition and the theorem that no request meets it. A string-matching test, not a theorem: a planted defect fails it.",
      "where": "crates/conformance/tests/ciris_deferral.rs"
    },
    {
      "name": "ciris_deferral_cd_03",
      "what": "CD-03's condition and the theorem that no request meets it. A string-matching test, not a theorem: a planted defect fails it.",
      "where": "crates/conformance/tests/ciris_deferral.rs"
    },
    {
      "name": "ciris_deferral_cd_04",
      "what": "CD-04's condition and the theorem that no request meets it. A string-matching test, not a theorem: a planted defect fails it.",
      "where": "crates/conformance/tests/ciris_deferral.rs"
    },
    {
      "name": "ciris_deferral_cd_05",
      "what": "CD-05's condition and the theorem that no request meets it. A string-matching test, not a theorem: a planted defect fails it.",
      "where": "crates/conformance/tests/ciris_deferral.rs"
    }
  ],
  "trusted": [
    {
      "name": "SDK image",
      "value": "the digest prismpm.lock pins; see the bootstrap workflow's log"
    },
    {
      "name": "Lean toolchain",
      "value": "leanprover/lean4:v4.32.1"
    },
    {
      "name": "LexLean compiler semantics",
      "value": "5262e5b4c8b5668ae7066ad686757a6bb7f80c941d515fb9d586894fbc7de69a"
    },
    {
      "name": "prism-code runtime, vendored",
      "value": "0.2.0, see try/vendor/prism-code/VENDOR.md"
    },
    {
      "name": "Your browser",
      "value": "runs the WebAssembly guest and this page"
    }
  ],
  "attestations": {
    "proof": {
      "id": "not recorded: the proof ran in the SDK image, not on the UOR MCP server",
      "url": "https://github.com/afflom/prism-ciris/actions/workflows/bootstrap.yml"
    },
    "build": {
      "id": "printed by prismpm verify in every pages run",
      "url": "https://github.com/afflom/prism-ciris/actions/workflows/pages.yml"
    }
  },
  "repository": "https://github.com/afflom/prism-ciris",
  "report": "https://github.com/afflom/prism-ciris/blob/main/TEMPLATE-VERIFICATION.md"
}
openspec/specs/ciris-deferral/spec.md 183 lines
# ciris-deferral Specification

<!-- Generated by Prism from prism/spec.json. Change the app through your agent with /prism, not by editing this file. -->

## Purpose

Wise deferral: Decide whether an agent proceeds, defers to a wise authority, or is halted, from its confidence margin, the diversity of its perspectives, the conscience gate and the Wise Authority seats that signed a halt.

## Requirements

### Requirement: Never proceed when conscience is vetoed

The app SHALL NOT answer `proceed` when conscience is vetoed, because the conscience gate is a non-bypassable final veto.

Verified: to be proved by Lean for every request (INV-001, theorem `inv001Holds`).

#### Scenario: INV-001 holds

- **WHEN** the request is `75 8 vetoed 0` (an acceptance example)
- **THEN** the answer SHALL NOT be `proceed`
- **AND** the app answers `defer`, decided by REQ-002

### Requirement: Never proceed when keff is below 4

The app SHALL NOT answer `proceed` when keff is below 4, because a monoculture of perspectives never acts alone.

Verified: to be proved by Lean for every request (INV-002, theorem `inv002Holds`).

#### Scenario: INV-002 holds

- **WHEN** the request is `35 2 passed 0` (an acceptance example)
- **THEN** the answer SHALL NOT be `proceed`
- **AND** the app answers `defer`, decided by REQ-003

### Requirement: Never proceed when margin is below 15

The app SHALL NOT answer `proceed` when margin is below 15, because the agent does not act on a near tie.

Verified: to be proved by Lean for every request (INV-003, theorem `inv003Holds`).

#### Scenario: INV-003 holds

- **WHEN** the request is `8 5 passed 0` (an acceptance example)
- **THEN** the answer SHALL NOT be `proceed`
- **AND** the app answers `defer`, decided by REQ-004

### Requirement: Always halt when seats is at least 2

The app SHALL answer `halt` when seats is at least 2, because a 2-of-3 Yubikey quorum always halts.

Verified: to be proved by Lean for every request (INV-004, theorem `inv004Holds`).

#### Scenario: INV-004 holds

- **WHEN** the request is `35 6 passed 2` (an acceptance example)
- **THEN** the answer SHALL be `halt`
- **AND** the app answers `halt`, decided by REQ-001

### Requirement: Never halt when seats is below 2

The app SHALL NOT answer `halt` when seats is below 2, because yubikeySingleSeatCannotHalt: one seat alone cannot halt.

Verified: to be proved by Lean for every request (INV-005, theorem `inv005Holds`).

#### Scenario: INV-005 holds

- **WHEN** the request is `35 6 passed 0` (an acceptance example)
- **THEN** the answer SHALL NOT be `halt`
- **AND** the app answers `proceed`, decided by the fallback

### Requirement: REQ-001 halt when seats is at least 2

The app SHALL answer `halt` when seats is at least 2, because src/Constitution.lex.tex checkYubikeyHaltQuorum: two of the three seats halt the agent (yubikeyTwoOfThreeQuorumHalts).

Verified: tested by the acceptance vectors (`rule1`).

#### Scenario: REQ-001 decides

- **WHEN** the request is `35 6 passed 2` (an acceptance example)
- **THEN** the answer SHALL be `halt`, decided by REQ-001

### Requirement: REQ-002 defer when conscience is vetoed

The app SHALL answer `defer` when conscience is vetoed and no earlier rule matches, because src/H3ERE.lex.tex decideOrDeferToWa: a failed conscience gate defers (conscienceVetoForcesDeferralOrHalt).

Verified: tested by the acceptance vectors (`rule2`).

#### Scenario: REQ-002 decides

- **WHEN** the request is `75 8 vetoed 0` (an acceptance example)
- **THEN** the answer SHALL be `defer`, decided by REQ-002

### Requirement: REQ-003 defer when keff is below 4

The app SHALL answer `defer` when keff is below 4 and no earlier rule matches, because src/H3ERE.lex.tex: k_eff below minimumEpistemicDiversityKeff, 4, defers (lowDiversityTriggersWisdomBasedDeferral).

Verified: tested by the acceptance vectors (`rule3`).

#### Scenario: REQ-003 decides

- **WHEN** the request is `35 2 passed 0` (an acceptance example)
- **THEN** the answer SHALL be `defer`, decided by REQ-003

### Requirement: REQ-004 defer when margin is below 15

The app SHALL answer `defer` when margin is below 15 and no earlier rule matches, because src/H3ERE.lex.tex: a margin below minimumConfidenceMargin, 15, defers (lowMarginTriggersWisdomBasedDeferral).

Verified: tested by the acceptance vectors (`rule4`).

#### Scenario: REQ-004 decides

- **WHEN** the request is `8 5 passed 0` (an acceptance example)
- **THEN** the answer SHALL be `defer`, decided by REQ-004

### Requirement: Otherwise proceed

The app SHALL answer `proceed` when no rule matches, because src/H3ERE.lex.tex highMarginAndDiversityPermitsAutonomousAction: conscience passed, diverse and confident.

Verified: tested by the acceptance vectors.

#### Scenario: No rule matches

- **WHEN** the request is `35 6 passed 0` (an acceptance example)
- **THEN** the answer SHALL be `proceed`

### Requirement: The first matching rule decides

The app SHALL try REQ-001, REQ-002, REQ-003, REQ-004 in that order, and the first rule that matches SHALL decide.

Verified: tested by the acceptance vectors.

#### Scenario: Two rules match

- **WHEN** the request is `0 0 passed 0`
- **THEN** the answer SHALL be `defer`, decided by REQ-003, the earlier rule

### Requirement: Request and answers

The app SHALL read one request as one line of 4 fields separated by single spaces, in this order, and SHALL answer exactly one of `proceed`, `defer`, `halt`, or `invalid` for anything else.

| Field | Accepts | Means |
| --- | --- | --- |
| `margin` | whole number from 0 up to 100 | the top score minus the runner-up score |
| `keff` | whole number from 0 up to 22 | the Kish effective number of independent perspectives |
| `conscience` | `passed`, `vetoed` | what the H3ERE-06 conscience gate said |
| `seats` | whole number from 0 up to 3 | Wise Authority Yubikey seats that signed a halt |

| Answer | Means |
| --- | --- |
| `proceed` | the agent acts autonomously |
| `defer` | a Wise Authority decides, wisdom-based deferral |
| `halt` | the agent stops, by a 2-of-3 Yubikey quorum |
| `invalid` | the request is malformed |

Verified: reading a request is tested, not proved.

#### Scenario: A malformed request is invalid

- **WHEN** the request is not 4 fields in this order
- **THEN** the answer SHALL be `invalid`

## Examples

- `35 6 passed 0` gives `proceed`
- `8 5 passed 0` gives `defer`
- `35 2 passed 0` gives `defer`
- `75 8 vetoed 0` gives `defer`
- `35 6 passed 2` gives `halt`
- `35 6 passed 1` gives `proceed`

## What is proved and what is tested

Lean proves each property marked proved above, for every request that decodes, with no exceptions and no sampling. The proof is about `judge`, the function the WebAssembly guest runs, because both come from the same model.

The parsing of requests is tested, not proved: the acceptance vectors in the app replay through the built guest, including malformed and oversized requests.

Nothing here says the rules are the right rules. That is the part only you can judge.

## Files

- `prism/spec.json` is this spec as data.
- `src/CirisDeferral.lex.tex` is the LexLean model generated from it. It is the single source of the app.

how-to guideBuildexampleMarkdown

Words on this page 7
record
One entry in a facet: a component, a threat, a measure or a journey step, with the place in the source it came from.
LexLean
The language Prism models are written in. It reads like LaTeX and compiles to Lean 4.
Lean kernel
The small checker at the heart of the Lean prover. It accepts a proof only if every step follows the rules.
theorem
A statement about the model that the Lean kernel has checked, so it holds for every input, not only the ones tested.
SDK
Software development kit. Here, the PrismPM container image that builds, checks and verifies Prism models.
stakeholder
A person or group with an interest in the system, as ISO/IEC/IEEE 42010 defines it.
decision table
A table of rules, as in OMG DMN 1.5: each row says which inputs lead to which outcome.